Energy Markets Quantitative Analysis

Lecture 5 · Derivatives and hedging

The slide of the lecture is on the left, the same figure on the right, recomputed in your browser from the course data (data/clean) when you move a control. The ▶ button moves the main parameter step by step. Under each figure: a readout, a question for the room and the Quantlet with the code of the chart.

Forwards, futures and the forward curve · Spreads: the margins of power plants · Hedge ratio, basis risk and shape risk · Options on energy

Forwards, futures and the forward curve

The Romanian forward curve slopes down from a high spot

Slide 16: The Romanian forward curve slopes down from a high spot
Slide 16

    Code of this chart: EMQA_L5_fwd_curve · open in Colab

    Question for the room At the end of October 2026, the October day-ahead average in Romania was 239.32 EUR/MWh, while the calendar 2027 baseload traded at 148.12 EUR/MWh. Does the downward slope of the curve mean that the market expects spot prices to fall by about 90 EUR/MWh?
    Answer

    Not exactly. A forward price is the expected spot price plus a risk premium, and part of the gap is seasonal: November and December 2026 traded at 215.33 and 214.27 EUR/MWh, the first quarter of 2027 at 176.69 and the whole year at 148.12, which also averages the cheap solar summer. Move the slider back: in 2022 the curve sloped down from a crisis spot, and the Cal-2023 product (calendar year 2023) traded at up to 509.18 EUR/MWh, while 2023 delivered 103.74 EUR/MWh on the day-ahead market.

    Spreads: the margins of power plants

    Monthly clean spark and clean dark spreads

    Slide 23: Monthly clean spark and clean dark spreads
    Slide 23

      Code of this chart: EMQA_L5_spreads · open in Colab

      Question for the room With the course assumptions (gas plant efficiency 50%, coal 38%), the Romanian clean spark spread was negative in 67 of 138 months. What happens to this count if the gas plant is a modern combined cycle with an efficiency of 58%?
      Answer

      The count falls, because a higher efficiency lowers both the fuel cost and the carbon cost per MWh of electricity: clean spark spread = p − gas/η − (0.202/η)·EUA. At 0.58 the count falls from 67 to 29 months. The clean dark spread of coal does not change with the gas slider: the switch between gas and coal depends on the relative cost, not on the price of power alone.

      Hedge ratio, basis risk and shape risk

      Cross-border hedges: Hungarian contracts are more effective than German ones

      Slide 28: Cross-border hedges: Hungarian contracts are more effective than German ones
      Slide 28

        Code of this chart: EMQA_L5_hedge_scatter · open in Colab

        Question for the room Monthly changes of the Romanian price are hedged with the Hungarian price. Over 2015–2026 the minimum-variance hedge ratio is h* = 0.966. Is the hedge ratio with the German price lower, and why?
        Answer

        Yes: h* = 0.875 with R² = 0.80, against R² = 0.98 for Hungary. The hedge ratio is h* = ρ·σ_RO/σ_F; Romania and Hungary are coupled and often share the same price, while Germany is farther away in the grid and its price moves partly for other reasons (wind, solar, its own interconnections). The variance left after the hedge is 1 − R²: about 2% with Hungary and about a fifth with Germany.

        The basis became more volatile after 2021, though RO and HU often share a price

        Slide 30: The basis became more volatile after 2021, though RO and HU often share a price
        Slide 30

          Code of this chart: EMQA_L5_basis · open in Colab

          Question for the room The basis is the difference between the Romanian price and the price of the hedging instrument. Did the RO–HU basis become more or less volatile after 2021?
          Answer

          More volatile: the standard deviation of the monthly RO–HU basis rises from 2.82 EUR/MWh before 2021 to 5.77 EUR/MWh from 2021, and that of RO–DE from 7.61 to 18.23 EUR/MWh. At the same time Romania and Hungary still share exactly the same price in many hours (the right panel): a basis that is usually zero but occasionally large is the typical risk left by a cross-border hedge.

          Options on energy

          The Samuelson effect in TTF: higher volatility of near contracts

          Slide 37: The Samuelson effect in TTF: higher volatility of near contracts
          Slide 37
          TTF contracts

            Code of this chart: EMQA_L5_samuelson · open in Colab

            Question for the room Over the last 12 months, the TTF contract for December 2026 had an annualised volatility of 63.0%, the May 2027 contract 47.7%. Why does the nearer contract move more?
            Answer

            This is the Samuelson effect: shocks to supply and demand (storage, weather, cargoes of LNG, liquefied natural gas) mostly affect the price for delivery soon, and are expected to fade before a distant delivery month. As expiry approaches, the futures price behaves more and more like the spot price, and its volatility rises. In 2022 the difference was small (66.1% against 66.8%): in a crisis even distant months moved as much as the front.

            Effective price of the 2027 band by instrument

            Slide 39: Effective price of the 2027 band by instrument
            Slide 39

              Code of this chart: EMQA_L5_collar · open in Colab

              Question for the room With F = 148.12 EUR/MWh, σ = 22.0%, 45 days to expiry and r = 2.44%, the at-the-money call costs 4.55 EUR/MWh. How much does a cap at 1.1·F cost, and how much does a collar 0.9·F – 1.1·F cost?
              Answer

              The cap (a call with strike 162.93) costs 0.63 EUR/MWh, about 5,500 EUR for 1 MW over a year; selling a put with strike 133.31 (0.43 EUR/MWh) brings the collar to 0.20 EUR/MWh. The buyer gives up the gains below the floor in exchange for a cheaper cap. Raise σ to 50% (close to the volatility of near TTF contracts): the at-the-money call rises to 10.33 and the collar to 0.88 EUR/MWh, and the call and the put at K = F stay equal, as put–call parity requires (C − P = e−rT(F − K)).

              Forward trades: OPCOM (Romanian power exchange), PCCB-LE-flex and related forward markets, baseload ("banda") products, prices converted to EUR/MWh at the ECB (European Central Bank) EUR/RON rate. Day-ahead prices: OPCOM PZU, HUPX, EPEX via energy-charts.info. TTF (Title Transfer Facility) gas: World Bank monthly series and single futures contracts; EUA (EU Allowance) carbon prices: EEX auctions; coal: World Bank (South Africa, Richards Bay); €STR (euro short-term rate): ECB. Monthly averages only for complete months. Data to the cut-off of the lecture (31 October 2026).