Modelling Financial Markets

Chapter 20 · Path Signatures and Realised Volatility

The slide of the lecture is on the left, the same figure on the right, computed in the browser from the same data. The ▶ button moves the parameter step by step.

The VOLARE Database · Results · Ablations and Robustness · Case Study: The Signature as a Lead-Lag Metric

The VOLARE Database

Realised Volatility Across Asset Classes

Slide 13: Realised Volatility Across Asset Classes
Slide 13
    Question for the room We keep the same scale. When ▶ widens the moving-average window of the annualised volatility from 5 to 65 days, what happens to the crude-oil (CL) maximum in the first half of 2020?
    Answer

    It falls, from 458% (five days ending 22 April 2020) to 152% (65 days ending 3 June 2020). A longer averaging window mixes the extreme values with quieter days. The option “unchanged” confuses the smoothed series with the original observations; “rises” confuses a mean with a sum. With the five-day mean, ES reaches 115% in March, JPM 111% and NVDA 118%, while EURUSD and USDJPY stay near 20%. The median volatility per class is 17.1% for stocks, 19.7% for futures and 7.3% for FX.

    Results

    QLIKE Relative to HAR, Asset by Asset

    Slide 41: QLIKE Relative to HAR, Asset by Asset
    Slide 41
      Question for the room At h = 1, across all 50 assets, the mean QLIKE ratio of Sig-L to HAR is 0.886. We switch the benchmark from HAR to log-HAR. Where will the mean of the Sig-L ratios lie?
      Answer

      Above 1: the mean Sig-L/log-HAR ratio is 1.004, so Sig-L has a slightly higher relative loss in this sample; for Sig-LK, 1.045. When the benchmark changes, the page recomputes the ratio of each asset and then averages; it does not divide the two means. A value of 1 is guaranteed only for the benchmark compared with itself. Relative to HAR, the means are 0.883 for log-HAR, 0.885 for log-HAR-K and 0.886 for Sig-L. These means are not a significance test.

      Model Confidence Sets

      Slide 45: Model Confidence Sets
      Slide 45
        Question for the room We keep QLIKE and all 50 assets. When ▶ raises the MCS confidence level from 90% to 99%, what happens to the share of assets for which Sig-LK stays in the set?
        Answer

        It rises or stays the same. The elimination threshold α falls from 0.10 to 0.01, and the page keeps the models with an MCS p-value above the threshold, so it eliminates fewer. For Sig-LK, the shares go from 100%, 94% and 88% to 100%, 100% and 100% at h = 1, 5 and 22; for log-HAR, from 100%, 98% and 98% to 100%. A higher confidence level does not mean a more restrictive selection. Membership of the MCS does not establish equal accuracy: at 90%, the four log models are rarely separated, while HAR, HARQ and SHAR are excluded for a fifth to a third of the assets.

        Inside the COVID-19 Crash: JPM, Next Day

        Slide 49: Inside the COVID-19 Crash: JPM, Next Day
        Slide 49
          Question for the room At h = 1, which of the three displayed forecasts captures the size of the target jump for the 11 March 2020 origin of JPM volatility?
          Answer

          None. At this origin, the next-day target is about 139%, while the forecasts are 59% (HAR), 49% (log-HAR) and 60% (Sig-LK): all strongly underestimate the jump. The somewhat faster later reaction of Sig-LK in mid-March and the later overshooting of the target by HAR do not show that either anticipated this jump. The raw HAR forecast turns negative in late March; the chart shows the value after the positivity rule (the mean target of the training window), and the 7 replaced origins are marked with ×.

          Stress Periods vs Normal Times (H4)

          Slide 51: Stress Periods vs Normal Times (H4)
          Slide 51
            Question for the room At h = 1, in the COVID-19 crash, the mean QLIKE ratio Sig-LK/HAR is 0.73. Is this sufficient to credit the signature procedure with a gain over log-HAR?
            Answer

            No. The value 0.73 shows an advantage over HAR; with the same benchmark, however, log-HAR has 0.70, so the results show no additional advantage of Sig-LK. On the other days, the ratios are 0.94 (log-HAR) and 0.97 (Sig-LK). At h = 22, in the same crash, Sig-LK has 6.35 times and Sig-L 8.30 times the HAR loss. The results give no descriptive support to H4; they are not a formal test of the difference between periods.

            Kernel Weights at the Origin 16 March 2020

            Slide 53: Kernel Weights at the Origin 16 March 2020
            Slide 53
              Question for the room At the 16 March 2020 origin, with N = 3, ▶ raises c from 0.5 to 8. What happens to the mean effective sample size over the 40 stocks?
              Answer

              It falls, from about 975 to 36 of 1,000. The weights are proportional to exp(−c δ / median of δ), where δ is the distance between windows: a larger c concentrates them on the small distances. The number of observations stays 1,000; the effective size falls. With c = 0.5, the average weight stays between 0.61 and 1.43 times 1/n; with c = 8, between 0.10 and 157 times 1/n. The highest weights go to the last days before the origin, whose 22-point windows overlap the current window. Translation invariance does not mean equal distances between windows.

              Ablations and Robustness

              The 2 × 2 Ablation

              Slide 55: The 2 × 2 Ablation
              Slide 55
                Question for the room At h = 1, the mean QLIKE ratio Sig-LK/log-HAR over the 50 assets is 1.045, and the largest ratio is that of crude oil (CL). If we leave CL out, does the mean fall below 1?
                Answer

                No: the mean falls from 1.045 to 1.011, so leaving CL out does not reverse the descriptive ranking. CL has a ratio of 2.71, but the effect of leaving it out also depends on the other 49 ratios. The weights alone (log-HAR-K) give 1.002, 1.002 and 1.004 relative to log-HAR at h = 1, 5 and 22; Sig-L gives 1.004, 1.285 and 2.238; Sig-LK, 1.045, 1.280 and 1.929. Sig-L evaluates the procedure with signatures and LASSO selection, so its difference from log-HAR cannot be attributed to the features alone.

                Case Study: The Signature as a Lead-Lag Metric

                SPY and Bitcoin at Five Minutes: Who Moves First?

                Slide 62: SPY and Bitcoin at Five Minutes: Who Moves First?
                Slide 62
                  Question for the room Across all 489 days, what is the longest tested window for which the mean Lévy area between SPY and Bitcoin is positive and significant at 5% after the Holm correction for the 20 tests?
                  Answer

                  120 minutes: NW t ≈ 3.05 and Holm-adjusted p ≈ 0.032. At 195 minutes, NW t ≈ 2.45 passes the pointwise 1.96 threshold, but the adjusted p is 0.157. The 10-minute option confuses the window with the strongest signal (t = 9.6, the area positive on 70% of the days) with the longest significant window; 195 minutes uses the pointwise threshold instead of the correction. Over the whole session, t = 1.51. The correlation between SPY at t − 1 and BTC at t is 0.088 (NW t = 9.8), and in the reverse direction −0.005. The 20 tests (12 lags and 8 windows) are exploratory, and the result indicates a lead-lag association, not causality. The effect weakens in 2026: the lag +1 correlation falls to 0.04.

                  Realised variance from the VOLARE database (Cipollini et al., 2026): 40 US stocks (2015–2026), 5 futures and 5 currency pairs (2009–2026), five-minute returns. VOLARE data are licensed for research use and are not redistributed; only summaries appear here: per-asset mean losses and MCS p-values, kernel weights and distances, five-day means of the volatility of the six assets on the slide (one value per week), and the JPM forecasts of February–May 2020. The lead-lag case study uses the five-minute bars of SPY and Bitcoin (EODHD, data/market/intraday): the cross-correlations and mean Lévy areas of each day.