Modelling Financial Markets

Chapter 3 · Factor Models and Asset Pricing

The slide of the lecture is on the left, the same figure on the right, computed in the browser from the same data. The ▶ button moves the parameter step by step.

From Markowitz to the CAPM · Estimating Beta · Testing the CAPM · Multifactor Models · Fama–MacBeth Regressions · Factor Investing · Further Topics: Latent Factors, PCA · Further Topics: Factor Momentum · Further Topics: Arbitrage and the Decay of Momentum

From Markowitz to the CAPM

The Efficient Frontier of US Sectors

Slide 8: The Efficient Frontier of US Sectors
Slide 8
    Question for the room SPY has a Sharpe ratio of 0.49 and the tangency portfolio of the sectors 0.66. Does this distance reject the CAPM?
    Answer

    No. The tangency portfolio is optimised in sample, so the difference requires a statistical assessment. The GRS test on the nine sectors, with Mkt-RF as the market, gives GRS = 0.53, with p = 0.85: we do not reject the CAPM at 5%, which does not establish that the model is correct. The tangency portfolio holds large short positions: −0.37 in XLF and −0.21 in XLB.

    Estimating Beta

    The Beta of the Technology ETF (XLK) in the Data

    Slide 14: The Beta of the Technology ETF (XLK) in the Data
    Slide 14
      Question for the room The standard error of the XLK beta is 0.041 with the classical formula and 0.082 with Newey–West. Does the estimate beta = 1.277 change as well?
      Answer

      No. Newey–West retains the OLS coefficients and changes their estimated covariance matrix; it neither reweights observations nor applies shrinkage. Beta remains 1.277. Estimated annual alpha is 0.33%, with t = 0.13. The 95% bootstrap interval, [−5.5%, 4.9%], includes zero: we do not reject zero alpha at 5%.

      Choices That Change an Estimated Beta

      Slide 17: Choices That Change an Estimated Beta
      Slide 17
        Question for the room In this simulation, true beta is 1 and the stock trades on 75% of the days; the contemporaneous slope in the Dimson regression is 0.77. As the trading probability rises from 75% to 100%, how does this slope change?
        Answer

        The contemporaneous slope rises from 0.77 to approximately 1.00. With daily trading, non-trading days no longer delay the response. The Dimson sum is approximately 0.98; in a finite sample it need not equal 1 exactly. At 75%, the slope on the previous-day market return is 0.16, and the Dimson sum 0.93.

        Betas Are Not Constant

        Slide 18: Betas Are Not Constant
        Slide 18
          Question for the room In these data, how does the range of rolling XLE beta estimates change when the window increases from 252 to 504 days?
          Answer

          The range changes from [−0.31, 1.49] to [0.20, 1.38]. The longer window smooths the observed variation. This does not establish that true beta is constant. The XLF beta moves between 0.60 and 2.17 at 252 days, with its maximum right after the 2008–2009 banking crisis.

          Testing the CAPM

          The Test Assets: 25 Size × B/M Portfolios

          Slide 24: The Test Assets: 25 Size × B/M Portfolios
          Slide 24
            Question for the room Over July 1963–July 2026, what happens to the small-value minus small-growth difference when we switch from mean excess returns to CAPM alphas?
            Answer

            The difference increases from approximately 9.46 to 12.00 percentage points a year: the mean returns are 3.9% for small growth and 13.3% for small value, and the CAPM alphas −6.3% and +5.7%. Small-growth beta is approximately 1.42, versus 1.06 for small value; CAPM subtracts a larger market component from small-growth returns. The adjustment does not subtract the same amount from both returns.

            The Security Market Line in the Data

            Slide 25: The Security Market Line in the Data
            Slide 25
              Question for the room From 1963, the line fitted on the 25 portfolios has a slope of −4.4% a year. When the sample start reaches January 2003, what happens to this slope?
              Answer

              For January 2003–July 2026, the fitted slope is approximately +2.0% a year, while the market premium is 10.7%. The slope's sign depends on the sample: it is −4.4% when starting in 1963 and −1.0% when starting in 2006. From 1963, the betas cover only 0.86–1.42, and GRS = 4.20, with p = 7.5 × 10−11 (rounded on the slide: 8 × 10−11).

              Multifactor Models

              Cumulative Returns of the Six Factors, 1963–2026

              Slide 39: Cumulative Returns of the Six Factors, 1963–2026
              Slide 39
                Question for the room From July 1963, MOM ends at 48.0 and Mkt-RF at 43.2. If we move the start to January 2016 and retain July 2026 as the endpoint, which compounded index will have the higher final value?
                Answer

                Mkt-RF reaches approximately 3.4, versus 1.0 for MOM. Starting in July 1963, the ranking was reversed: MOM reached 48.0 and Mkt-RF 43.2. These indices multiply (1 + the monthly factor return), starting from 1; they do not automatically represent investable strategies with identical financing. Momentum lost heavily when the market rebounded in 2009.

                Fama–MacBeth Regressions

                Estimated Risk Premia

                Slide 44: Estimated Risk Premia
                Slide 44
                  Question for the room In FF3, the Fama–MacBeth market premium is −6.5% a year, while the mean of the factor is 7.2%. Why are they so far apart?
                  Answer

                  Market betas vary little across portfolios: 0.89–1.14 in FF3. This limited dispersion makes it difficult to separate the market premium from the intercept. The negative estimate does not establish investors' preferences for risk. The Shanken correction changes standard errors, not the premium estimate. For HML, the estimated premium (4.0%) is close to the factor mean (3.6%).

                  Factor Investing

                  Factor ETFs versus the Market

                  Slide 57: Factor ETFs versus the Market
                  Slide 57
                    Question for the room IWF has a CAGR of 16.3%, versus 14.0% for SPY over the same period. Is the 2.3-percentage-point difference an estimate of IWF's CAPM alpha?
                    Answer

                    No. The CAGR difference describes realised compounded performance. CAPM alpha is the intercept in a regression of excess asset returns on excess market returns. Diversification does not impose a beta of 1. A conclusion about alpha requires its estimate and uncertainty. Since July 2013, only IWF and MTUM (15.5%) have a CAGR above SPY; QUAL has 13.5%, VLUE 13.1%, IWD 10.7%, USMV 10.5% and IWM 9.3%.

                    Further Topics: Latent Factors, PCA

                    PCA of the US Sector ETFs

                    Slide 67: PCA of the US Sector ETFs
                    Slide 67
                      Question for the room Over the full sample, PC1 explains 66.0% of the total variance of the standardised returns of the 11 sectors. If we select the 252-day window ending on 18 September 2026, what share does PC1 explain?
                      Answer

                      PC1 explains 36.6%, versus 66.0% in the full sample. Standardisation equalises the variances of the 11 input series, not those of the principal components. PC1's share is recomputed from the selected window's correlations. Over the full sample, the PC1 loadings are all positive (0.24–0.34) and the correlation of PC1 with SPY is 0.954; over the 252-day window it is 0.723.

                      Further Topics: Factor Momentum

                      Factor Momentum in the French Factors, 1964–2026

                      Slide 72: Factor Momentum in the French Factors, 1964–2026
                      Slide 72
                        Question for the room The average factor earns 0.47% a month after a positive prior year and 0.05% after a negative one. Does this factor momentum explain all of the MOM alpha?
                        Answer

                        No. The FF5 alpha of MOM falls from 0.74% a month (t = 4.18) to 0.32% (t = 2.27) when TSFM is added, i.e. by 57%. With seven factors, factor momentum explains just over half of the MOM alpha, and the rest remains significant at 5%; the paper, with many more factors, explains most forms of momentum.

                        Further Topics: Arbitrage and the Decay of Momentum

                        Mini-Case: Was Momentum Arbitraged Away?

                        Slide 77: Mini-Case: Was Momentum Arbitraged Away?
                        Slide 77
                          Question for the room After the 1993 publication, the momentum mean falls by 0.45 percentage points a month, with t = −1.45. If the estimate stays unchanged but its standard error is halved, do we reject H₀: b₂ = 0 in a two-sided 5% test using the asymptotic critical value 1.96?
                          Answer

                          Yes. The t-statistic is the estimate divided by its standard error. Halving the standard error doubles the absolute t-statistic: 2.90 > 1.96. In the actual calculation, t = −1.45, the 95% interval is [−1.05%, 0.16%], and we do not reject. Even statistical significance would not by itself establish that publication caused the decline. The decline is 54% of the in-sample mean of 0.82% a month, close to the 58% in McLean and Pontiff (2016).

                          US ETFs: EODHD prices adjusted for dividends; excess returns use the risk-free rate of the Kenneth French Data Library. Fama–French factors, momentum, reversal and the 25 size × B/M portfolios: Kenneth French Data Library. Dimson beta: simulated data.