Modelling Financial Markets

Chapter 5 · GARCH Models

The slide of the lecture is on the left, the same figure on the right, computed in the browser from the same data. The ▶ button moves the parameter step by step.

Motivation: Forecasting Conditional Volatility · Variance Dynamics · Estimation and Uncertainty · Forecasts and Results by Market · Asymmetry and Model Choice · Innovations and Diagnostics · Forecasting and Forecast Evaluation · Extensions and Limits · Case Studies: Quasi Score-Driven Volatility and Volatility Cycles

Motivation: Forecasting Conditional Volatility

Volatility Clusters in Every Market

Slide 4: Volatility Clusters in Every Market
Slide 4
    Question for the room On the S&P 500, how often is a day with |r| above 3 standard deviations followed by another such day within the next 5 days?
    Answer

    In 62% of the cases. The threshold is exceeded on 105 days (1.6% of the days); with independent days, the probability would be 8%. The share is 54% for BET and 32% for Bitcoin.

    Predictability of the Sign and of the Size of Returns

    Slide 6: Predictability of the Sign and of the Size of Returns
    Slide 6
      Question for the room At lag 1, the autocorrelation of S&P 500 returns is −0.099 and that of their squares 0.313; squared-return autocorrelations stay positive and persistent. What follows for modelling?
      Answer

      Dependence in return magnitudes can exist without strong linear dependence in returns. All 50 autocorrelations of r² lie outside the ±0.024 band; for r, 15 of 50 do, but all are small. Small autocorrelations do not imply independence, and squared-return autocorrelations do not measure sign-forecast accuracy. The ±0.024 band is a pointwise asymptotic reference under the i.i.d. assumption.

      Variance Dynamics

      Simulation: GARCH Produces Clustering

      Slide 15: Simulation: GARCH Produces Clustering
      Slide 15
        Question for the room The innovations z are Normal. Do the returns of a GARCH(1,1) with α = 0.10 and β = 0.88 have fat tails?
        Answer

        Yes, the unconditional return distribution has theoretical excess kurtosis of approximately 3.06. The fourth moment is finite because 0.98² + 2 × 0.10² = 0.9804 < 1. The conditional distribution is Normal; the unconditional distribution mixes different variances. Estimated excess kurtosis is 0.40 on the page's 2,000-day path and 2.47 on the lecture's million-day path: kurtosis is estimated imprecisely on short samples.

        Estimation and Uncertainty

        Near-Unit Persistence: What the Delta Method Can and Cannot Do

        Slide 24: Near-Unit Persistence: What the Delta Method Can and Cannot Do
        Slide 24
          Question for the room The estimated half-life for the S&P 500 is 132 days, with a standard error of 118 days, and 132 ± 1.96 × 118 has a lower endpoint of −99 days. We replace this negative endpoint with zero. Does this justify approximately 95% coverage?
          Answer

          No. Removing negative values does not justify coverage. The problem is the curvature of h(p) near 1: the delta-method tangent falls below zero. Transforming the p < 1 portion of the persistence interval, [0.9856, 1.0039], gives a lower endpoint of about 48 days and no finite upper endpoint; values p ≥ 1 do not describe a shock that halves.

          Forecasts and Results by Market

          Volatility Term Structure

          Slide 30: Volatility Term Structure
          Slide 30
            Question for the room On 18.09.2026, the GARCH(1,1)-t forecast of S&P 500 volatility for the next day is 11.3% a year, and at the 250-day horizon the curve shows 20.1%. What does the 20.1% value represent?
            Answer

            The page computes √(A · H−1 Σj=1H Et[σ2t+j]), where A is the number of returns per year. Averaging precedes taking the square root. At H = 250 the result is 20.1%; it is neither average volatility nor the final day's volatility. The forecast rises towards the long-run level of 27.4%, because the current level is below it. For gold the curve falls from 24.0% to 22.5%; for Bitcoin α̂ + β̂ = 1 and the 250-day value is 108.3%.

            Persistence: How Fast Do Shocks Fade?

            Slide 33: Persistence: How Fast Do Shocks Fade?
            Slide 33
              Question for the room We double the initial variance shock while keeping the GARCH parameters fixed. What happens to its half-life?
              Answer

              It stays unchanged. The remaining effect is proportional to the initial shock, but the remaining fraction is ph. Half-life depends on p, not amplitude: about 132 days for the S&P 500 and 8.18 days for BET-TR. After 100 days, 59% of the shock is left for the S&P 500 and practically nothing for BET-TR. For Bitcoin and EUR/RON α̂ + β̂ = 1, so in the model the shocks never fade.

              S&P 500: GARCH Volatility and the VIX

              Slide 34: S&P 500: GARCH Volatility and the VIX
              Slide 34
                Question for the room The correlation between the GARCH(1,1)-t volatility and the VIX is 0.89, and the VIX is higher on average: 19.8% against 17.0%. Does this gap measure the variance risk premium?
                Answer

                No. The variance risk premium compares VIX² with a 30-day variance forecast under the physical probability, while σ̂ is a one-day volatility, filtered with the parameters estimated on the full sample. The VIX exceeds the GARCH volatility on 84% of the days.

                Asymmetry and Model Choice

                The News Impact Curve for the S&P 500

                Slide 38: The News Impact Curve for the S&P 500
                Slide 38
                  Question for the room With σ²(t−1) = 1.47 %², GJR-GARCH-t forecasts 3.16 %² after a −3% shock and 1.31 %² after a +3% shock. Keep the shocks and double the previous variance without re-estimating. How does the difference between the two variance forecasts change?
                  Answer

                  It remains approximately 1.85 %². The difference is γ × 3² ≈ 1.846 %². The previous-variance term increases equally for both signs and cancels from the difference. Doubling previous variance does not double the asymmetry; the percentage shocks remain fixed. At σ²(t−1) = 1.47, EGARCH gives 2.75 and 1.22, and GARCH(1,1) gives 2.40 for both shocks.

                  Innovations and Diagnostics

                  S&P 500: Are the Innovations Normal?

                  Slide 42: S&P 500: Are the Innovations Normal?
                  Slide 42
                    Question for the room 16 standardised residuals of GARCH(1,1) with Normal innovations lie below −4, against 8.6 expected under a Student-t with ν ≈ 6.25. Increase ν to 30 while keeping the residuals fixed and the Student-t variance equal to 1. What changes below −4?
                    Answer

                    The slider changes the reference distribution, not the estimated residuals. The 16 observations remain unchanged. The expected count under the Student-t falls from about 8.6 to about 0.9 at ν = 30; 0.21 are expected under the Normal distribution. The excess kurtosis falls from 10.7 (returns) to 1.73 (residuals), but normality is clearly rejected: Jarque–Bera 1,156.

                    Forecasting and Forecast Evaluation

                    Out-of-Sample Design and Forecast Paths, 2016–2026

                    Slide 47: Out-of-Sample Design and Forecast Paths, 2016–2026
                    Slide 47
                      Question for the room We choose λ = 0.93 because it minimises EWMA QLIKE on the grid evaluated over 2016–2026. Is QLIKE on that same period an out-of-sample evaluation of the choice of λ?
                      Answer

                      No. Forecasts for a fixed λ use past data, but retrospective selection of λ uses outcomes from the entire period. The grid minimum is about 0.812, versus 0.814 at λ = 0.94 and 0.731 for GJR-t. Evaluating the selection procedure requires a separate period or rolling selection. Against GARCH-t, the DM t of EWMA with λ = 0.94 is 3.47.

                      S&P 500: Does Anything Beat GARCH(1,1)?

                      Slide 48: S&P 500: Does Anything Beat GARCH(1,1)?
                      Slide 48
                        Question for the room For GJR-t relative to GARCH-t, mean QLIKE differs by −0.025 and the DM statistic is −1.22. What conclusion do these results support?
                        Answer

                        GARCH-t is nested in GJR-t, and the estimated-model forecasting scheme does not automatically justify a standard Normal reference for DM. The negative difference describes the observed average advantage. It establishes neither statistical superiority nor equal accuracy. EWMA (t = 3.47) and Hist-20 (t = 4.10) have larger losses; with MSE the ranking changes: EGARCH-t has the lowest value, 21.30.

                        Extensions and Limits

                        Long Memory: the Shape of the ACF of |r|

                        Slide 51: Long Memory: the Shape of the ACF of |r|
                        Slide 51
                          Question for the room For the geometric curve ρk = ρ₁pk−1, does p = 0.9948 establish long memory?
                          Answer

                          No. High persistence is not the same as long memory. For this curve, the autocorrelations sum to ρ₁/(1 − p), which is finite. Separately, the empirical fit is imperfect: with ρ₁ = 0.289, least squares over 250 lags gives p ≈ 0.9875, rather than the initial value of 0.9948; the curve falls too fast at first (0.258 against 0.295 at lag 10) and too slowly afterwards (0.156 against 0.132 at lag 50). The data have 0.289 at lag 1, 0.083 at lag 100 and 0.013 at lag 250.

                          Case Studies: Quasi Score-Driven Volatility and Volatility Cycles

                          Case Study: Replication on 11 Stocks (cf. Paper, Fig. 2)

                          Slide 58: Case Study: Replication on 11 Stocks (cf. Paper, Fig. 2)
                          Slide 58
                            Question for the room For Apple, increase ζ from 0.15 to 0.30 without re-estimating. How does the contribution of a standardised shock ε = 5 to the QSD update change?
                            Answer

                            It decreases. The contribution, in units of αft, decreases from approximately 6.46 to 4.11. For this large shock, increasing ζ strengthens downweighting. The density parameter ξ remains separate from ζ in QSD. Across the 11 stocks, ξ̂ > ζ̂ for 10 (the exception is Cisco); the LR test rejects ξ = ζ at 5% for 8 stocks and ζ = 0 (the GARCH-t update) for 9.

                            S&P 500: The Slow Volatility Component and Forecasts Months Ahead

                            Slide 60: S&P 500: The Slow Volatility Component and Forecasts Months Ahead
                            Slide 60
                              Question for the room Over 2010–2026, month-8 relative QLIKE is 0.911 for MF2-GARCH and 0.838 for GJR-GARCH; the DM t-statistic for MF2−GJR is 0.99. Does a one-sided test support GJR superiority at 5%?
                              Answer

                              No. Under the lecture's asymptotic approximation, the one-sided threshold is 1.645. The statistic of 0.99 does not exceed it. GJR has lower average loss in this sample, without evidence of superiority at 5%; this does not establish equality. Over 2010–2019 the ranking was reversed: 0.714 for MF2-GARCH and 0.806 for GJR-GARCH (DM t −2.66).

                              Daily log returns in %, closes up to 18 September 2026: S&P 500, BET, BET-TR, Bitcoin, gold (XAU/USD) and the VIX, EODHD prices; EUR/RON: the BNR reference rate. Case studies: 11 S&P 500 stocks, 1995–2019, and the S&P 500, 1990–2026, EODHD prices.