The slide of the lecture is on the left, the same figure on the right, computed in the browser from the same data. The ▶ button moves the parameter step by step.
Stability under Summation · The Generalised Central Limit Theorem · Parameters and the Characteristic Function · Tails and Moments · Simulation · Estimation · Fitting Real Returns · Critique of the Stable Model: Finite or Infinite Variance
Stability under Summation
Stability in a Simulation
Answer
About 7.27. Divided by 501/1.7 = 9.98, the same sum has a 99% quantile of 5.15, the law of a single draw. The √n rule understates the scale of the sum by the factor n1/α − 1/2, which grows with n: 100.088 = 1.23 and 500.088 = 1.41. With infinite variance, more terms do not bring the sum closer to the rule of the Normal distribution.
Consequences: Horizons and Diversification
Scale factor of the n-day sum and of the portfolio of N assets (γ = 1)
Worked example: the scale of n-day risk, with the fitted α̂ and γ̂
Answer
2.51 times: 2501/1.5 = 39.69, against √250 = 15.81. The ratio is n1/α − 1/2 = 2501/6, so it grows with the horizon. With α̂ = 1.540 fitted to the S&P 500, the ratio is 1.56 at 20 days and 2.28 at 250 days. For an equally weighted portfolio of N = 10 assets, the scale falls to 0.46γ for α = 1.5, against 0.32γ for the Normal distribution.
The Generalised Central Limit Theorem
The GCLT in a Simulation
Answer
17.2%, close to 19.2% for the sums with n = 100 and to 21.7% for the stable limit. The same interquartile range makes the bodies of the two laws similar; the difference is far in the tails: at the threshold 10, 0.0005% against 2.73% in the simulation. The ▶ button shows how the ratio grows with the threshold.
Parameters and the Characteristic Function
The Effect of α
Answer
The density at x = 5. f(0) rises from 0.2821 to 0.2874, by 1.9%, and f(5) rises from 0.000545 to 0.00711, 13 times. On the linear scale the curves look close; the log scale shows that α changes mainly the tails. P(|X| > 5) is 0.041% for α = 2 and 4.14% for α = 1.5.
The Effect of β and γ
Answer
About 3 times: the ratio is 3.29 at the threshold 10 and tends to (1 + β)/(1 − β) = 1.5/0.5 = 3, from the tail formula P(X > x) ∼ cα(1 + β)x−α and P(X < −x) ∼ cα(1 − β)x−α. At the threshold 3 the probabilities are 10.8% and 3.37%. With β = 1, the left tail falls much faster than x−α.
S1 vs S0 near α = 1
Answer
At about 50.5, far outside the chart. The shift between the two parameterisations is β tan(πα/2) = 0.8 × 63.66 = 50.93, and the mode in S0 is −0.38. At α = 1.01 the tangent changes sign and the mode in S1 moves to about −51. In S0 the mode stays between −0.48 and −0.26 over the whole range.
Normal, Cauchy and Lévy
Answer
The Lévy law: 17.7%, against 1.59% for the Cauchy and about 3 × 10−87% for the Normal distribution. The Lévy tail falls as x−1/2 (α = 1/2), the Cauchy tail as x−1. For x = 3 the probabilities are 43.6% (Lévy), 10.2% (Cauchy) and 0.13% (Normal distribution).
Worked Example: S1 vs S0 at t = 1
The location gap between S0 and S1
Worked example: φ(t) in S1 and in S0
Answer
For α = 1.1: β tan(πα/2) = 0.3 × (−6.314) = −1.894, against 0.3 × (−0.158) = −0.048 for α = 1.9. The tangent goes to infinity as α approaches 1, which is why the S1 parameterisation moves the density a lot around α = 1 and S0 does not. The modulus |φ(t)| = e−|t|α is the same in both parameterisations; only the argument differs, by a term linear in t.
Tails and Moments
Tails on Log-Log Axes
Answer
0.0165%: doubling the threshold divides the probability by about 21.9 = 3.7 (the exact ratio is 0.256, the power law gives 2−1.9 = 0.268). With α close to 2 the tail is still a power law, far from the Normal distribution, for which P(X > 10) is of the order of 10−12.
Instability of the Sample Variance
Answer
No: 3.16, 2.62 and 4.12, against 1.96 for the Normal distribution. For any α < 2 the variance is infinite and each large draw makes a jump. With α = 1.95 the final values are 2.46, 2.22 and 2.83; only α = 2 gives 2.00, 1.97 and 1.99. With α = 1.7 (the slide): 10.4, 6.6 and 20.2.
Tail Probabilities: Stable vs Normal
Answer
0.52%, that is 94% of the exact value. At k = 20 the approximation gives 0.161% against 0.166% exact (97%), and at k = 2 only 8.1% against 18.6%: the tail formula is asymptotic and becomes accurate far in the tail. The ratio to the Normal distribution N(0, 2) is 1.2 at k = 2 and 3.6 × 109 at k = 10.
Simulation
Worked Example: One Draw Step by Step
Worked example: one CMS draw from (U, W)
Answer
1.843. For β = 0, W enters only through the factor (cos((1 − α)V)/W)(1 − α)/α; the exponent (1 − α)/α = −1/3 is negative, so X grows in proportion to W1/3: 1.554 × (2/1.2)1/3 = 1.843. A smaller W shrinks the draw: W = 0.5 gives 1.161. For α = 2 the formula becomes 2 sin V √W, a draw from N(0, 2): 1.772 for U = 0.8 and W = 1.2.
CMS Draws against the Exact Density
Answer
Mirrored: −9.79 and 5.39 exactly, −9.81 and 5.38 on the FFT grid of the chart (in the simulated sample −9.99 and 5.21). In S1 with δ = 0, the law with −β is the law with β reflected about 0, so β changes which tail is longer, not only the location. The histogram follows the exact density for every combination of α and β.
Estimation
McCulloch's Map from ν_α to α
Answer
No, it rises to 1.543: να falls from 3.338 to 3.044. The McCulloch estimator uses only the 5%, 25%, 50%, 75% and 95% quantiles, so the extreme days do not enter the calculation directly; what matters is how wide the 5–95% band is relative to the interquartile range. The DAX goes from 1.455 to 1.590, BET from 1.414 to 1.480, Bitcoin from 1.322 to 1.400.
Worked Example: McCulloch on the BET
The McCulloch estimator on daily log returns (%)
Worked example: from the quantiles to α̂, β̂, γ̂ and δ̂0
Answer
About 1.53: between να = 3.0 ↦ 1.563 and να = 3.2 ↦ 1.484, linear interpolation gives 1.531, and with |νβ| = 0.036 the result is α̂ = 1.529. A smaller να means a narrower 5–95% band relative to the interquartile range, hence thinner tails and a larger α̂. The Normal distribution has να = 2.439 and α = 2.
McCulloch vs ML in a Monte Carlo Study
Answer
Yes: from 0.050 to 0.061. The precision of α̂ depends on the sample size n; the number of Monte Carlo samples only determines how well this precision is measured. With 100 samples, the estimated standard deviation still has a relative error of at least 1/√(2 × 100) = 7%. For McCulloch, 0.110 at 100 and 0.107 at 200.
Fitting Real Returns
Stable Fits of Daily Log Returns
Stable laws (S0) fitted to daily log returns
Worked example: the location from S0 to S1
Answer
For all four. At 99% (±2.576 standard errors) the intervals are BET [1.435, 1.537], S&P 500 [1.486, 1.594], DAX [1.551, 1.661] and Bitcoin [1.343, 1.476], and the McCulloch α̂ is 1.414, 1.438, 1.455 and 1.322. Not even at 99.9% does the conclusion change (Bitcoin: lower bound 1.324). The two methods weigh the tails differently. The intervals are asymptotic and do not include the uncertainty of the McCulloch estimate.
Fitted Densities on a Log Scale
Answer
About 120,000 times: 4.4 × 10−9 against 5.5 × 10−4. The stable density is 1.0 × 10−3, almost twice the Student-t density. The Normal tail falls as e−x²/2, the other two as a power of x, so the ratio grows very fast with |x|.
Fitted Densities on a Log Scale
Answer
About 2.9 times: 3.7 × 10−4 against 1.3 × 10−4. The stable tail falls as |x|−α̂−1 with α̂ = 1.61, the Student-t tail as |x|−ν̂−1 with ν̂ = 3.09; a smaller exponent means a heavier tail. The ratio is 1.6 at −5 standard deviations and 3.9 at −10.
QQ Plots against the Three Models
Answer
19.70%, 2.7 times the empirical quantile. The Student-t gives 8.58%, the Normal distribution 3.72%. At p = 1%, the values are 3.45% (data), 4.54% (stable), 3.46% (Student-t) and 2.80% (Normal): the stable law already overstates, but the gap grows as p gets smaller.
QQ Plots against the Three Models
Answer
The Student-t: 11.06%. The stable law gives 14.26%, the Normal distribution 7.99%. At p = 0.1%, the data give 18.05%, the Student-t 31.95% and the stable law 74.16%: the Student-t also overstates the far tail of Bitcoin, but much less than the stable law.
The Left Tail on Log-Log Axes
Answer
57.3, 2.5 times as many. The Student-t expects 27.0, the Normal distribution 0.1. For losses above 10%: one day observed, 4.5 under the Student-t and 19.1 under the stable law. The ratio between the days expected by the stable law and those observed grows with the threshold.
The Left Tail on Log-Log Axes
Answer
12.3 under the Student-t and 26.9 under the stable law; the Normal distribution gives practically zero. Both heavy-tailed models overstate the far tail of Bitcoin, the stable law more than 6 times. For losses above 10%: 56 observed, 54.2 (Student-t), 73.9 (stable).
Counting Large Losses
Days with losses above x%: observed and expected (n × P(r < −x)) under each fitted model
Worked example: the power-law tail of the fitted stable law
Answer
18.3 days, 96% of the exact value: c1.540 = 0.1868, P ≈ 0.1868 × 1.181 × 17.33−1.540 = 0.00273. The factor 1 − β̂ = 1.181 comes from β̂ = −0.181: the left tail of the fitted law is heavier than the right one. Observed: a single day. For Bitcoin at 10%, the approximation gives 68.2 days, against 73.9 exact and 56 observed.
VaR 1% and VaR 0.1% under the Three Models
VaRp = −qp from the data and from the three fitted models (% a day)
Worked example: VaR from the fitted stable law and from the Normal distribution
Answer
About 7.9: 31.21% against 3.97%. The ratio grows as p falls, because the quantile of the stable law grows like p−1/α and the Normal one only like √(2 ln(1/p)). The empirical quantile at 0.05% is 9.31%, so the stable law exceeds the data 3.4 times. At 5% the stable/Normal ratio is 0.91: in the body of the distribution, the stable law gives a smaller VaR.
Comparison of the Three Models
Answer
98.4 points. The stable law has one more parameter (4 against 3), and BIC penalises it by ln 6,714 = 8.81 instead of 2: 91.6 + 6.8 = 98.4. The conclusion does not change. Against the Normal distribution, the AIC gains of the Student-t lie between 1,306 (DAX) and 2,411 (BET) points, those of the stable law between 1,204 and 2,319, as on the slide.
Critique of the Stable Model: Finite or Infinite Variance
Test 1: Stability of α under Aggregation
Answer
No. At 99% (±2.576 standard errors), the daily interval is [1.486, 1.594] and the monthly one [1.655, 1.984]. Not even at 99.9% (±3.29 standard errors) do they overlap, although the gap between them almost vanishes. For the DAX and BET the intervals already overlap at 95%. The intervals are asymptotic, and the monthly one rests on 321 months.
Test 2: Convergence of the Sample Variance
Answer
Much higher: 252.1, 111.4 and 52.6, 4 to 21 times the variance of the data. The same holds for the S&P 500 (the slide): data 1.47, paths 5.9, 5.4 and 15.6. A stable law with α̂ < 2 produces extremes that the real series do not have, and their sample variance does not settle.
Daily log returns, in %: BET, S&P 500 and DAX from January 2000, Bitcoin from September 2014 (7 days a week), to 18 September 2026. EODHD closing prices. The fitted laws are those of the lecture: the Normal distribution, the Student-t and the stable law fitted by maximum likelihood in the S0 parameterisation.






















