Statistics of Financial Markets

Chapter 4 · Probability

The slide of the lecture is on the left, the same figure on the right, computed in the browser from the same data. The ▶ button moves the parameter step by step.

Origins of Probability Theory: Games of Chance and Axioms · Random Variables and Distributions · Expectation and Variance · Joint Distributions and Dependence · Conditional Expectation and Conditional Variance · The Law of Large Numbers and the CLT · Random Numbers and Monte Carlo · The Binomial Model · Discrete-Time Stochastic Processes · The Wiener Process and Geometric Brownian Motion

Origins of Probability Theory: Games of Chance and Axioms

Example: Down Days in a Row

Slide 8: Example: Down Days in a Row
Slide 8

Conditional probabilities of the event D, daily log returns

    Question for the room For the S&P 500, P(down today | down yesterday) = 43.4% is even below P(down) = 46.3%. The ▶ button raises the threshold x: the event D becomes a loss of more than x%. At x = 2%, what is P(D | D yesterday) against P(D) = 4.27%?
    Answer

    11.85%, 2.8 times P(D). Two losses of more than 2% in a row have a frequency of 0.51%, against 0.18% under independence. The sign of the return barely persists for the S&P 500, but large losses come in clusters: volatility clustering. For BET the sign persists too, at x = 0: 50.0% after a down day against 42.6% after a day that is not down, an effect of thin trading.

    Random Variables and Distributions

    A Discrete and a Continuous Random Variable

    Slide 13: A Discrete and a Continuous Random Variable
    Slide 13
      Question for the room For the S&P 500, the variance of K (1.16) is slightly below the binomial variance 5p(1 − p) = 1.24. The ▶ button moves to the DAX and BET. What happens for BET, whose daily return has a first-order autocorrelation of 0.109?
      Answer

      The variance of K exceeds the binomial value: 1.47 against 1.24, ratio 1.18. The binomial distribution assumes independent days; with the positive autocorrelation of BET returns, up days come one after another more often, so weeks with many or with few up days are more frequent. The mean stays close to 5p: 2.67 against 2.70. For the S&P 500, with autocorrelation −0.099, the ratio is 0.93; for the DAX also 0.93.

      Empirical CDF and the 1% Quantile of the S&P 500

      Slide 14: Empirical CDF and the 1% Quantile of the S&P 500
      Slide 14
        Question for the room At the 1% level, the empirical VaR of the S&P 500 (3.45%) is 1.24 times the VaR of the Normal distribution with the same mean and standard deviation (2.80%). The ▶ button lowers the level α from 5% to 0.1%. What does the ratio become at α = 0.1%?
        Answer

        About 1.94: VaR 0.1% is 7.22% in the data and 3.72% under the Normal distribution. At α = 5% the ratio is 0.94 (1.85% against 1.97%). If the difference were only one of scale, the ratio would be the same at every level; it grows towards the tail, so the problem is the shape of the distribution: a higher peak and heavier tails. P(r < −5%) is 0.34% in the data and 1.7 × 10−3% under the Normal distribution, 199 times less.

        Expectation and Variance

        Worked Example: Annual Mean and Volatility

        Slide 18: Worked Example: Annual Mean and Volatility
        Slide 18

        Moments of the daily log returns (%)

        Worked example: the mean and volatility over h days

        \[E\Big[\sum_{t=1}^{h} r_t\Big] = h\,\bar r, \qquad \mathrm{Var}\Big(\sum_{t=1}^{h} r_t\Big) = h\,\sigma^2 \;\Rightarrow\; \sigma_h = \sigma\sqrt{h}\]
            Question for the room Bitcoin trades every day, so the chapter annualises with A = 365. The daily standard deviation is 3.485%. What is the annual volatility?
            Answer

            66.6% = 3.485 × √365. With A = 252, as for stocks, it would be 55.3%. The annual mean is 43.1% with A = 365 (29.8% with A = 252). The volatility grows with √A, the mean with A, and both assume i.i.d. returns. The excess kurtosis of 11.96 shows that the daily distribution is not Normal, even though the square-root-of-time rule uses only the variance.

            Frequency of 4-Sigma Days: Chebyshev's Bound

            Slide 19: Frequency of 4-Sigma Days: Chebyshev's Bound
            Slide 19

            Days with |r − mean| > kσ: data, the Normal distribution and Chebyshev's bound

            Worked example: Chebyshev's bound against the data

            \[P(|X - \mu| \ge k\sigma) \le \frac{1}{k^2}, \qquad P(|X - \mu| > k\sigma) = 2\Phi(-k) \;\text{ for } X \sim N(\mu, \sigma^2)\]
                Question for the room For k = 2, Chebyshev's inequality allows up to 25% of the days. What share of the S&P 500 days lies more than 2 standard deviations from the mean?
                Answer

                4.90% (329 days), close to 4.55% under the Normal distribution. At 2 standard deviations the data look like the Normal distribution; the difference is in the tail: at k = 4 there are 46 days (0.69%), 108 times the 0.0063% of the Normal distribution, and at k = 6 there are 12 days, against 1.3 × 10−5 expected days. Chebyshev's bound, 1/k², holds for any distribution with finite variance, which is why it lies far above the data.

                Joint Distributions and Dependence

                Joint Distributions of Daily Returns

                Slide 23: Joint Distributions of Daily Returns
                Slide 23
                  Question for the room The daily correlation of the S&P 500 and BET over the whole period is 0.21. What is it on the days of 2020?
                  Answer

                  0.63, on 242 common days, three times the value over the whole period. In 2008 the correlation is 0.28, in 2017 0.20. For the S&P 500 and the DAX: 0.69 in 2020, 0.62 in 2008 and 0.57 in 2017, against 0.60 over the whole period. Correlation rises in crisis years, exactly when diversification would be needed.

                  Worked Example: a 50/50 Portfolio of S&P 500 and DAX

                  Slide 24: Worked Example: a 50/50 Portfolio of S&P 500 and DAX
                  Slide 24

                  Variances, covariances and correlations of daily returns (%)

                  Pairs of series on their common days

                  Worked example: the volatility of the a/b portfolio

                  \[\begin{gathered}\sigma_p^2 = a^2\sigma_1^2 + b^2\sigma_2^2 + 2ab\,\mathrm{Cov}(X, Y), \qquad b = 1 - a,\\ \rho = \frac{\mathrm{Cov}(X, Y)}{\sigma_1\sigma_2}, \qquad a^* = \frac{\sigma_2^2 - \mathrm{Cov}(X, Y)}{\sigma_1^2 + \sigma_2^2 - 2\,\mathrm{Cov}(X, Y)}\end{gathered}\]
                      Question for the room The ▶ button moves the weight a of the S&P 500 in the S&P 500/DAX portfolio from 0 to 1. At which weight is the volatility of the portfolio lowest?
                      Answer

                      At a* = (σ2² − Cov)/(σ1² + σ2² − 2Cov) = 0.69, with σp = 1.163%, against 1.186% at a = 0.5. The S&P 500 gets the larger weight because its volatility is lower (1.221% against 1.429%), but not 1: with ρ = 0.60, some DAX still reduces the risk. For S&P 500/BET, with ρ = 0.21: a* = 0.60 and σp = 1.025%.

                      Autocorrelation of Returns and of Squared Returns

                      Slide 26: Autocorrelation of Returns and of Squared Returns
                      Slide 26
                        Question for the room The ▶ button raises the lag h from 1 to 20. At h = 20, is Corr(rt², rt−20²) of the S&P 500 still outside the band ±1.96/√n = ±0.024?
                        Answer

                        Yes: 0.164 at lag 20, against 0.313 at lag 1, while the correlation of the returns at lag 20 is 0.014, inside the band. At lag 1, the correlation of the squares is 0.31 (S&P 500), 0.15 (DAX), 0.33 (BET) and 0.14 (Bitcoin). At lag 20 it stays above the band for the DAX (0.116) and BET (0.090); for Bitcoin (0.026) it falls inside the band ±0.030. Volatility clustering lasts for weeks. The band is an asymptotic reference value for an i.i.d. series, not an exact test at every lag.

                        Conditional Expectation and Conditional Variance

                        Worked Example: Two Regimes

                        Slide 30: Worked Example: Two Regimes
                        Slide 30

                        Two regimes: the components of the variance

                        Worked example: the mean and the total variance

                        \[E[r] = \sum_j \pi_j \mu_j, \qquad \mathrm{Var}(r) = \underbrace{\sum_j \pi_j \sigma_j^2}_{E[\mathrm{Var}(r \mid X)]} + \underbrace{\sum_j \pi_j (\mu_j - E[r])^2}_{\mathrm{Var}(E[r \mid X])}\]

                          The data: rt by the quintile of |rt−1|

                            Question for the room In the two-regime example, the standard deviation of the return is 1.286%. What does it become if the turbulent regime has a standard deviation of 3% instead of 2%?
                            Answer

                            1.776%: the within-regime variance rises to 0.7 × 0.8² + 0.3 × 3² = 3.148, and the between-regime component stays at 0.0047, so Var(r) = 3.153. The weighted average of the standard deviations, 0.7 × 0.8 + 0.3 × 3 = 1.46%, understates the risk: variances add, not standard deviations. In the data, for the S&P 500, the between-quintile component is 0.009% of the total variance.

                            Today's Return Given Yesterday's Move

                            Slide 31: Today's Return Given Yesterday's Move
                            Slide 31
                              Question for the room With 5 groups (quintiles), the ratio of the standard deviations of the most turbulent and the calmest group is 1.88 for the S&P 500. The ▶ button goes from 2 to 10 groups. What does the ratio become with 10 groups?
                              Answer

                              2.22: 2.03% in the most turbulent group against 0.92% in the calmest. With 2 groups the ratio is 1.43: the extreme groups are more extreme when they are narrower. The between-group component of the total variance stays negligible: 0.054% of the total with 10 groups, 0.009% with 5. Yesterday's move says a lot about today's risk and almost nothing about today's mean.

                              The Law of Large Numbers and the CLT

                              Two Limit Theorems

                              Slide 34: Two Limit Theorems
                              Slide 34

                              S&P 500: the running mean after n days

                              Worked example: the standard error of the mean

                              \[\bar r_n = \frac1n\sum_{t=1}^n r_t, \qquad \mathrm{SE} = \frac{s}{\sqrt n}, \qquad t = \frac{\bar r_n}{s/\sqrt n}, \qquad n_{t = 2} = \Big(\frac{2s}{\bar r}\Big)^2\]
                                  Question for the room Over 2000–2026, the daily mean of the S&P 500 has t = 1.67. With the same mean and volatility, how many years of data would give t = 2?
                                  Answer

                                  About 38 years: n = (2s/r̄)² = (2 × 1.213/0.0247)² = 9,633 days. t grows with √n, so a t that is 2/1.67 = 1.20 times larger needs 1.43 times as many days. A standard error half as large needs four times as many days (26,856). The running mean from 2000 is still negative after 100, 1,000 and 2,500 days.

                                  The LLN for the Mean Return: Slow Convergence

                                  Slide 35: The LLN for the Mean Return: Slow Convergence
                                  Slide 35
                                    Question for the room Over 2000–2026, the daily mean of the S&P 500 has t = 1.67. The ▶ button moves the start of the sample from 2000 to 2020. What is t for the sample that starts in 2009?
                                    Answer

                                    2.83: the daily mean is 0.0480% (12.1% per year), the standard error 0.0169%. The sample from 2009 starts after the 2008 crisis. From 2003, t = 2.38; from 2020, t = 1.64 with only 1,687 days. The 95% interval of the annual mean is [3.7%, 20.4%] from 2009 and [−1.1%, 13.5%] from 2000. The estimated mean depends strongly on the start of the sample; a start chosen after looking at the data no longer gives a valid test.

                                    Random Numbers and Monte Carlo

                                    Worked Example: an LCG with M = 16

                                    Slide 38: Worked Example: an LCG with M = 16
                                    Slide 38

                                    M = 16: the period for every multiplier a, with the chosen c and x0

                                    Worked example: the steps of an LCG and its period

                                    \[x_{k+1} = (a\,x_k + c) \bmod M, \qquad u_k = \frac{x_k}{M}, \qquad M = 16\]
                                        Question for the room With a = 4, c = 1 and x0 = 7, after how many steps does the sequence get stuck, and at which value?
                                        Answer

                                        After two steps: x1 = 29 mod 16 = 13, x2 = 53 mod 16 = 5, then 4 × 5 + 1 = 21 ≡ 5, so the sequence stays at 5 (period 1). With M = 16 and an odd c, the maximal period 16 occurs exactly when a − 1 is a multiple of 4 (a = 1, 5, 9, 13, the Hull–Dobell condition); a = 1, however, gives the sequence 7, 8, 9, …, with a maximal period and nothing random about it.

                                        RANDU: Random Numbers Fall Mainly in the Planes (SFErandu)

                                        Slide 39: RANDU: Random Numbers Fall Mainly in the Planes (SFErandu)
                                        Slide 39
                                          Question for the room The ▶ button changes the RANDU seed x0 (odd numbers from 1 to 99). How many distinct values does the combination 9uk − 6uk+1 + uk+2 take for x0 = 99?
                                          Answer

                                          15, from −5 to 9, as for every odd seed. The relation comes from the multiplier: 65539 = 216 + 3, so a² = 6a − 9 (mod 231) and xk+2 = 6xk+1 − 9xk (mod 231), whatever x0. The correlation of the pairs stays small (0.0078 for x0 = 99), so a test on pairs does not see the flaw. With PCG64, the combination takes 29,998 different values in 29,998 triples.

                                          The Inverse Transform Method

                                          Slide 40: The Inverse Transform Method
                                          Slide 40

                                          Worked example: the same u through three quantile functions

                                          \[\begin{gathered}X = F^{-1}(U), \qquad U \sim U(0, 1):\\ x = -\frac{\ln(1 - u)}{\lambda} \;\text{(exponential)}, \qquad x = \mu + \sigma\,\Phi^{-1}(u) \;\text{(Normal)}, \qquad x = \hat F^{-1}(u) \;\text{(historical)}\end{gathered}\]

                                            The left tail of the 200,000 draws of the lecture (S&P 500)

                                              Question for the room With λ = 2, the mean of the exponential distribution is 1/λ = 0.5. For which values of u does the draw x = −ln(1 − u)/2 exceed the mean?
                                              Answer

                                              For u > 1 − e−1 = 0.632: P(X > 0.5) = e−λ × 0.5 = e−1 = 36.8%. The median is ln 2/λ = 0.347, below the mean: the exponential distribution is skewed to the right. In the table, the 7 Normal draws below −5%, against 3.4 expected, differ by 1.9 Poisson standard deviations (√3.44 = 1.85): simulation noise, not a flaw of the method.

                                              Inverse Transform: Exponential, Normal and Historical

                                              Slide 41: Inverse Transform: Exponential, Normal and Historical
                                              Slide 41
                                                Question for the room Of the 200,000 draws from the Normal distribution, 7 (0.0035%) are below −5%. What does the exact Normal distribution, with the same mean and standard deviation, give for P(r < −5%)?
                                                Answer

                                                1.7 × 10−3%, i.e. 0.0017%, or 3.4 expected draws out of 200,000. With so few events, the standard deviation of the number of draws is about √3.4 ≈ 1.84, so 7 draws are simulation noise, not a flaw of the method. The historical draws give 0.34% (685 of 200,000), as the data: the inverse transform with the empirical quantile function reproduces the tail of the sample. At −8%: no Normal draw, 148 historical ones.

                                                Worked Example: a Monthly Loss Probability by Monte Carlo (2/2)

                                                Slide 43: Worked Example: a Monthly Loss Probability by Monte Carlo (2/2)
                                                Slide 43

                                                The Monte Carlo estimate and its standard error

                                                Worked example: the exact probability, the estimate and the standard error

                                                \[\begin{gathered}z = \frac{-L - h\,m}{s\sqrt h}, \qquad p = \Phi(z), \qquad \hat p_N = \frac{1}{N}\sum_{i=1}^N \mathbf 1\{R_i < -L\},\\ \mathrm{SE} = \sqrt{\frac{p(1 - p)}{N}}, \qquad N_{10\%} = \frac{1.96^2 (1 - p)}{0.1^2\,p}\end{gathered}\]
                                                    Question for the room For a monthly loss above 20%, p = 0.0112%. What is the standard error of the Monte Carlo estimate with N = 1,000 simulations?
                                                    Answer

                                                    √(p(1 − p)/N) = 0.0334%, three times p. With 1,000 simulations the estimate is 0 (no simulated month below −20%); with 100,000 it is 0.007%, with one million 0.0117% (standard error 0.0011%). For L = 10%, the standard error at N = 1,000 is 0.533%, i.e. 18% of p = 2.922%.

                                                    Convergence Rate of Monte Carlo: 1/√N

                                                    Slide 44: Convergence Rate of Monte Carlo: 1/√N
                                                    Slide 44
                                                      Question for the room For a monthly loss above 10%, a relative error of 10% (at 95%) needs N = 12,762 simulations. How many does the same precision need for a monthly loss above 15%?
                                                      Answer

                                                      About 146,000 (146,201): p falls from 2.922% to 0.262%, and N ≈ 1.96²(1 − p)/(0.1² p) grows almost as 1/p. For 20%, p = 0.0112% and N = 3.44 million; with one million simulations the estimate is 0.0117%, with standard error 0.0011%, about 10% of p. The absolute error √(p(1 − p)/N) falls with p, but the relative error grows.

                                                      The Binomial Model

                                                      Worked Example: a Two-Step Tree

                                                      Slide 47: Worked Example: a Two-Step Tree
                                                      Slide 47

                                                      The terminal nodes of the tree, S0 = 100 (highlighted rows: Sn < 100)

                                                      Worked example: the mean, the probability of a loss and p*

                                                      \[\begin{gathered}S_n = S_0\,u^K d^{\,n-K}, \qquad P(K = k) = \binom{n}{k} p^k (1 - p)^{n-k},\\ E[S_n] = S_0\big(pu + (1 - p)d\big)^n, \qquad p^* = \frac{1 - d}{u - d}\end{gathered}\]
                                                          Question for the room With S0 = 100, u = 1.2, d = 0.8 and p = 0.6, P(S2 < 100) = 0.64. What is P(S3 < 100) with three steps?
                                                          Answer

                                                          0.352: the nodes are 172.8, 115.2, 76.8 and 51.2, and below 100 are those with at most one up move: 0.4³ + 3 × 0.6 × 0.4² = 0.064 + 0.288. With two steps, the node ud = 96 was below 100 because ud = 0.96 < 1; with three steps, the node with two up moves is 115.2. The mean E[S3] = 100 × 1.04³ = 112.49 grows with n in any case.

                                                          Calibrating the Tree to a Market (Cox–Ross–Rubinstein)

                                                          Slide 48: Calibrating the Tree to a Market (Cox–Ross–Rubinstein)
                                                          Slide 48

                                                          The CRR tree calibrated to the S&P 500 (σ = 19.26%, μ = 8.08%), S0 = 100, T = 1 year

                                                          Worked example: P(ST ≤ 100) and P(ST < 100)

                                                          \[\begin{gathered}u = e^{\sigma\sqrt{\Delta t}}, \quad d = \frac1u, \quad p = \frac{e^{\mu\Delta t} - d}{u - d}, \qquad S_T = S_0\,u^{2K - n},\\ P(S_T \le S_0) = \sum_{k \le n/2} \binom{n}{k} p^k (1 - p)^{n-k}, \qquad P(S_T < S_0) = \sum_{k < n/2} \binom{n}{k} p^k (1 - p)^{n-k}\end{gathered}\]
                                                              Question for the room With 252 steps, P(ST ≤ 100) = 39.7%. What is the probability that ST is strictly below 100?
                                                              Answer

                                                              34.9%. The 39.7% is P(ST ≤ 100): it includes the node ST = 100 (k = 126 up moves), with probability C(252, 126)p126(1 − p)126 = 4.8%. The lognormal limit, 37.3%, is practically the average of the two values. With an odd number of steps there is no node at 100: 37.3% with 251 and with 253 steps.

                                                              Binomial Paths and the Lognormal Limit (SFEBinomp)

                                                              Slide 49: Binomial Paths and the Lognormal Limit (SFEBinomp)
                                                              Slide 49
                                                                Question for the room With 252 steps, P(ST ≤ 100) = 39.7%, against 37.3% in the lognormal limit. What is P(ST ≤ 100) with only 2 steps?
                                                                Answer

                                                                61.9%, of which 47.3% is the node ST = 100 (one up and one down move, ud = 1); P(ST < 100) is only 14.7%. With an even n, the tree has a node exactly at S0, with a probability that falls as 1/√n: 6.7% at 126 steps, 4.8% at 252. With 5 steps there is no such node and P(ST < 100) = 36.5%. The 39.7% of the slide is P(ST ≤ 100); strictly below 100 is 34.9%. E[ST] = 108.42 for every n, by the construction of p.

                                                                Discrete-Time Stochastic Processes

                                                                The AR(1) Process: Simulation

                                                                Slide 55: The AR(1) Process: Simulation
                                                                Slide 55

                                                                AR(1) with σ = 1: theoretical values, the 500 shocks of the chart and the long simulation of the lecture

                                                                Worked example: the variance, the autocorrelation and the half-life

                                                                \[X_t = \phi X_{t-1} + \varepsilon_t: \qquad \mathrm{Var}(X_t) = \frac{\sigma^2}{1 - \phi^2}, \qquad \rho(h) = \phi^h, \qquad h_{1/2} = \frac{\ln 0.5}{\ln \phi}\]
                                                                    Question for the room For φ = 0.5 the half-life of a shock is 1.0 periods, for φ = 0.95 it is 13.5. What is it for φ = 0.9?
                                                                    Answer

                                                                    ln 0.5/ln 0.9 = 6.6 periods. The stationary variance is 1/(1 − 0.81) = 5.26, and ρ(5) = 0.9⁵ = 0.590. On the 500 shocks of the chart, the sample variance of the process with φ = 0.9 is 6.44: with high persistence, 500 points contain few nearly independent stretches, and the sample variance moves away from the theoretical value.

                                                                    White Noise, AR(1) and Random Walk with the Same Shocks

                                                                    Slide 56: White Noise, AR(1) and Random Walk with the Same Shocks
                                                                    Slide 56
                                                                      Question for the room For φ = 0.95, the half-life of a shock is 13.5 periods. What is it for φ = 0.99?
                                                                      Answer

                                                                      ln 0.5/ln 0.99 = 69.0 periods, five times as long. The stationary variance 1/(1 − φ²) rises from 10.26 to 50.25, and ρ(5) = 0.99⁵ = 0.951. The process is still stationary and returns to 0, but over 500 points it is hard to tell from a random walk; only φ = 1 makes the shocks permanent.

                                                                      Question for the Room: Which One Is Real?

                                                                      Slide 57: Question for the Room: Which One Is Real?
                                                                      Slide 57
                                                                        Question for the room Which column is the S&P 500, judging by the returns?
                                                                        Answer

                                                                        Column C. The prices do not tell it apart: random walks with drift also have long rallies and falls. The returns do: excess kurtosis 10.67 against at most 0.02 in the simulations, Corr(rt², rt−1²) = 0.313 against at most 0.006, the largest daily move 12.8% against 6.2%. Beyond 4 standard deviations: 46 days in C, at most one in the simulated columns; beyond 6 standard deviations: 12 days in C, none in the simulations.

                                                                        The Wiener Process and Geometric Brownian Motion

                                                                        The Wiener Process as a Limit of Random Walks (SFEWienerProcess)

                                                                        Slide 62: The Wiener Process as a Limit of Random Walks (SFEWienerProcess)
                                                                        Slide 62
                                                                          Question for the room 68.2% of the 10,000 simulated values W(1) are within ±1. What share is within ±2?
                                                                          Answer

                                                                          95.37% in the simulation, theoretically 2Φ(2) − 1 = 95.45%, because W(1) ~ N(0, 1). Chebyshev's inequality only guarantees at least 1 − 1/2² = 75%, for any distribution with finite variance. The band ±k√t describes the distribution of W(t), not a bound on the paths: of the 20 paths of the chart, all end within ±2, but only 14 within ±1. For k = 3: 99.67% against 99.73%.

                                                                          GBM: Mean, Median and Simulation

                                                                          Slide 65: GBM: Mean, Median and Simulation
                                                                          Slide 65

                                                                          GBM calibrated to each series, S0 = 100

                                                                          Worked example: the mean, the median and the quantile of ST

                                                                          \[\begin{gathered}E[S_T] = S_0 e^{\mu T}, \qquad \mathrm{Me}(S_T) = S_0 e^{(\mu - \sigma^2/2)T}, \qquad q_\alpha(S_T) = S_0 e^{(\mu - \sigma^2/2)T + \sigma\sqrt T z_\alpha},\\ P(S_T < S_0) = \Phi\Big(-\frac{(\mu - \sigma^2/2)\sqrt T}{\sigma}\Big)\end{gathered}\]
                                                                              Question for the room GBM calibrated to Bitcoin has σ = 66.6% per year. How many times larger is the mean of S10 than the median?
                                                                              Answer

                                                                              eσ²T/2 = e0.666² × 5 = 9.2 times: mean 68,252, median 7,437. The ratio of the mean to the median depends only on σ²T. For the S&P 500 (σ = 19.26%) the ratio is 1.20 (224.4 against 186.4). The mean of a GBM is dominated by a few very large paths; a typical path follows the median.

                                                                              GBM Calibrated to the S&P 500 (SFEsimGBM)

                                                                              Slide 66: GBM Calibrated to the S&P 500 (SFEsimGBM)
                                                                              Slide 66
                                                                                Question for the room The ▶ button raises σ from 5% to 60%, with the same mean μ = 8.08% per year. For σ = 40%, where does the median of S10 end?
                                                                                Answer

                                                                                At 100.8 = 100e(0.0808 − 0.08) × 10: the log drift μ − σ²/2 falls to 0.08% per year. The mean stays at 224.4, because it depends only on μ. The probability of a loss after 10 years rises from 15.3% (σ = 19.26%) to 49.7%, and the share of paths below the mean, Φ(σ√T/2), from 62.0% to 73.6%. σ = 40% is an extra run of the chapter's formulas, not a result of the lecture.

                                                                                Real Paths in the GBM Fan

                                                                                Slide 67: Real Paths in the GBM Fan
                                                                                Slide 67
                                                                                  Question for the room With the 90% band, BET is outside the GBM fan on 24% of the days. What share does the 99% band give, where the nominal value would be 1%?
                                                                                  Answer

                                                                                  12.7%: less, but 13 times the nominal value; the boom of 2000–2007 and the crash of 2008 take the path far from GBM. S&P 500: 7.0% outside the 90% band and 0.0% outside the 99% band; Bitcoin: 4.5% and 0.1%. The days of a single path are not independent observations: the path stays on the same side of the median for a long time, so even the S&P 500 is outside the 50% band on 64.2% of the days.

                                                                                  Limitations of the GBM Model

                                                                                  Slide 68: Limitations of the GBM Model
                                                                                  Slide 68

                                                                                  Days with |r − mean| > k standard deviations: data, GBM simulations and the Normal distribution

                                                                                    Question for the room The ▶ button raises the threshold k from 3 to 8 standard deviations. At k = 6, how many days does the S&P 500 have, and how many does the most extreme of the 300 GBM simulations have?
                                                                                    Answer

                                                                                    12 days in the data and 0 in each of the 300 simulations. BET has 17 such days, Bitcoin 4. At k = 3, the S&P 500 has 105 days, against a GBM median of 18; at k = 8, still 4 days. Under the Normal distribution, the expected number of days beyond 6 standard deviations in 6,714 days is of the order of 10−5.

                                                                                    Daily log returns, in %: S&P 500, DAX and BET from January 2000, Bitcoin from September 2014 (7 days a week), to 18 September 2026. EODHD closing prices. The simulations are those of the lecture: the same models, the same numbers of paths and the same generator seeds.