Time Series Analysis

Chapter 5 · Conditional Volatility: ARCH and GARCH Models

The slide of the lecture is on the left, the same figure on the right, computed in the browser from the same data. The ▶ button moves the parameter step by step.

Stylised facts of financial returns · Conditional mean and conditional variance · The ARCH model · The GARCH(1,1) model · Estimation by maximum likelihood · GARCH in four markets and ARMA-GARCH models · Asymmetry and the leverage effect · Diagnostics and model choice · Variance forecasts and their evaluation · An application: VaR 1% from a GARCH model

Stylised facts of financial returns

Daily log returns in four markets

Slide 6: Daily log returns in four markets
Slide 6
    Question for the room In which year was the daily standard deviation of the S&P 500 returns lowest?
    Answer

    In 2017: 0.42%, followed by 2006 (0.63%) and 2005 (0.65%). From September 2008 to March 2009 the standard deviation was 3.52%, 8.3 times larger, and in February–May 2020 3.70% (8.8 times). For the EUR/RON the calmest year was 2024 (0.025%) and the most agitated 2008 (0.72%): the BNR kept the leu almost fixed in 2020, when equities went through their largest storm.

    Autocorrelation of returns and of squared returns

    Slide 10: Autocorrelation of returns and of squared returns
    Slide 10
      Question for the room Replace r² by |r|. How many of the 50 autocorrelations of |r| for the S&P 500 lie outside the band, and what is the autocorrelation at lag 50?
      Answer

      All 50 lie outside the band, and at lag 50 the autocorrelation is 0.127, against 0.053 for r²; at lag 1: 0.289 against 0.313. The absolute value is less dominated by a few extreme days than the square, so the memory of the size of returns shows even more clearly. The sign (r) stays almost unpredictable: 15 of 50 autocorrelations are outside the band, most of them small.

      Conditional mean and conditional variance

      The mean model leaves ARCH effects

      Slide 18: The mean model leaves ARCH effects
      Slide 18
        Question for the room Raise the AR order of the mean from 1 to 5. Do the ARCH effects of the residuals disappear?
        Answer

        No. Q(10) of the residuals falls from 29.7 to 15.4 (p = 0.009), but Q(10) of the squares rises from 2496 to 2562, and ARCH-LM(5) stays around 1020 (for AR(1): n R² = 6664 × 0.1526 = 1017). A richer model for the mean removes the autocorrelation of the level, not that of the squares: the conditional variance needs a model of its own. On the right, the same residuals divided by the GARCH(1,1) volatility lose their ARCH effects for every p: Q(10) of ẑ² stays between 7.0 and 8.3 (p > 0.6).

        The ARCH model

        Simulated paths: i.i.d., ARCH(1) and GARCH(1,1)

        Slide 24: Simulated paths: i.i.d., ARCH(1) and GARCH(1,1)
        Slide 24
          Question for the room Move α of ARCH(1) to 0.7 (ω = 0.3). What are the theoretical and the sample kurtosis?
          Answer

          In theory the fourth moment does not exist (3α² = 1.47 ≥ 1, the threshold is α = 1/√3 = 0.577), so the kurtosis is infinite. The kurtosis of the 1000 simulated values is 11.24, and 34.9 at α = 0.9: a finite sample always has a finite kurtosis, so the sample value cannot show that the moment does not exist. At α = 0.5 theory gives 9.0 and the sample 4.91: the fourth moment converges slowly.

          The GARCH(1,1) model

          GARCH, EWMA and a rolling window in 2020

          Slide 33: GARCH, EWMA and a rolling window in 2020
          Slide 33
            Question for the room Raise λ to 0.97. Is the EWMA peak of March 2020 higher or lower than 85%?
            Answer

            Lower: 67%, on 27 March 2020, against 85% on 25 March for λ = 0.94. With a larger λ the weight of yesterday’s return, 1 − λ, falls from 0.06 to 0.03, and the half-life of the weights rises from 11.2 to 22.8 days: the estimate reacts more slowly and comes down more slowly (37% on 30 June 2020, against 30%). With λ = 0.90 the peak is 103%, close to that of GARCH (111%), whose α = 0.123 is larger than 1 − λ = 0.06.

            Estimation by maximum likelihood

            The likelihood of ARCH(1)

            Slide 37: The likelihood of ARCH(1)
            Slide 37
              Question for the room Move the second sample to n = 5000. What does the standard error of α̂ become?
              Answer

              0.015 (α̂ = 0.516), against 0.035 for n = 1000: 2.3 times smaller, close to √5 = 2.24. The standard error falls with √n, because the log-likelihood is a sum of n terms and its curvature at the maximum grows in proportion to n.

              The likelihood of GARCH(1,1)

              Slide 38: The likelihood of GARCH(1,1)
              Slide 38
                Question for the room With n = 1000 in the right panel, where is the maximum on the grid?
                Answer

                At (0.045, 0.90): α is still underestimated and β overestimated, along the same ridge on which α + β changes little. With n = 1500 the maximum is at (0.075, 0.82), with n = 3000 at (0.10, 0.81), with n = 5000 at (0.10, 0.82). α and β trade off: different pairs with the same persistence give almost the same likelihood, which is why GARCH needs long samples.

                QQ plots of the standardised residuals

                Slide 43: QQ plots of the standardised residuals
                Slide 43
                  Question for the room For which ν does the theoretical 0.1% quantile of the standardised t equal the sample one, −4.79?
                  Answer

                  For ν ≈ 4.5 (−4.79), smaller than ν̂ = 6.26. But the t distribution is symmetric: with ν = 4.5 its 99.9% quantile is +4.79, while the sample one is only 2.93. The left tail of the residuals is heavier than the right one; a single ν cannot fit both, which is why the lecture also compares the skewed t distribution.

                  GARCH in four markets and ARMA-GARCH models

                  Conditional volatility: S&P 500 and BET

                  Slide 47: Conditional volatility: S&P 500 and BET
                  Slide 47
                    Question for the room Double α (c = 2) keeping α + β. What happens to the S&P 500 peak of March 2020 and to the median volatility?
                    Answer

                    The peak rises from 111% to 140% and the median falls from 14.3% to 13.3%: with α = 0.245 and β = 0.750 the volatility reacts more strongly to every shock and comes back faster. For the BET the 2008 peak rises from 117% to 138%. The persistence, and so the long-run level, stays the same; the shape of the path changes. The estimated values (c = 1) are those that maximise the likelihood.

                    Conditional volatility: EUR/RON and Bitcoin

                    Slide 48: Conditional volatility: EUR/RON and Bitcoin
                    Slide 48
                      Question for the room Halve α for Bitcoin (c = 0.5). Does the peak of 13 March 2020 fall below 250%?
                      Answer

                      Yes: 218%, against 301% with the estimated α; the median rises from 58.7% to 66.6%. In an IGARCH too, α decides how far volatility jumps after a shock; α + β = 1 only decides that the shock does not die out. For the EUR/RON, with c = 0.5, the 2008 peak falls from 22% to 19%.

                      How long does a volatility shock last?

                      Slide 49: How long does a volatility shock last?
                      Slide 49
                        Question for the room With α + β rounded to 0.995, the half-life of the S&P 500 comes out at 138 days. The table of the lecture gives 0.9947 and 131. Which is right?
                        Answer

                        131: the unrounded estimated persistence is 0.99471, and ln 0.5 / ln 0.99471 = 130.7 days. Rounding to three decimals adds 7 days; for the BET, 0.99071 gives 74.3 days, rounded to 0.991 it gives 76.7. Rounded to 0.99, both give 69.0 days. Close to 1 the half-life depends strongly on the third decimal: compute it from the unrounded value.

                        Forecast intervals with time-varying width

                        Slide 52: Forecast intervals with time-varying width
                        Slide 52
                          Question for the room With 99% coverage, what share of the days of March–April 2020 does the constant interval miss, and what share does the GARCH interval miss?
                          Answer

                          The constant interval misses 28.6% of the days, the GARCH interval 2.4%. Over the whole sample: 2.9% and 1.0%, and in 2017: 0.4% and 0.4%. The width of the constant interval is 7.2 points every day; that of the GARCH interval varies between 3.4 and 35.1 points in the window of the chart. The constant interval fails precisely in crises, when it matters most.

                          Asymmetry and the leverage effect

                          News impact curves: S&P 500 and Bitcoin

                          Slide 57: News impact curves: S&P 500 and Bitcoin
                          Slide 57
                            Question for the room For a shock of 4%, how many times larger is tomorrow’s variance of the S&P 500 after a fall than after a rise, in GJR?
                            Answer

                            3.50 times, against 1.62 for a shock of 2%. The ratio grows with the size of the shock: the term γε² grows with the square of the shock, while βσ² does not depend on it. EGARCH gives 2.97; the kernel estimate only 1.41, because there are few days with falls of 4%. For Bitcoin the GJR ratio stays close to 1 (0.98).

                            Diagnostics and model choice

                            What GARCH removes

                            Slide 61: What GARCH removes
                            Slide 61
                              Question for the room For the EUR/RON, Q(10) of ẑ² is 0.004 (p = 1.000). Is the GARCH-t model perfect?
                              Answer

                              No. The value comes from a single day, 6 May 2025, with ẑ = 153.7, whose square dominates all autocorrelations. Without that day, Q(10) = 19.2 (p = 0.038): ARCH effects remain, which the test with all days does not separate from noise. For the S&P 500, excluding the largest |ẑ| (27 February 2007) changes the result little (13.6 → 14.2).

                              Variance forecasts and their evaluation

                              The term structure of volatility

                              Slide 68: The term structure of volatility
                              Slide 68
                                Question for the room Move the origin to 16 March 2020. Is the 10-day volatility of the square-root-of-time rule larger or smaller than the one from the sum of the forecasts?
                                Answer

                                Larger: √(10 × 49.03) = 22.14% against √479.49 = 21.90%. On 18 September 2026 it was the other way round: 2.26% against 2.38%. In a crisis the forecast variance comes down towards the long-run level, so the square-root-of-time rule overstates; in a calm period it understates.

                                GARCH against EWMA, out of sample

                                Slide 70: GARCH against EWMA, out of sample
                                Slide 70
                                  Question for the room Remove the day with the largest loss difference. Does the difference between GARCH-t and EWMA for the EUR/RON become significant at 5%?
                                  Answer

                                  No: t = −1.32 (p = 0.187), against −1.02 (p = 0.310) with all days. The day of 6 May 2025 brought 98% of the total difference, and without it the mean QLIKE of the two models are close. For the BET, without 19 December 2018 the advantage of GARCH-t becomes clearer (t = −2.79, p = 0.005).

                                  An application: VaR 1% from a GARCH model

                                  VaR 1% through the COVID-19 crash

                                  Slide 75: VaR 1% through the COVID-19 crash
                                  Slide 75
                                    Question for the room At VaR 5%, in the window July 2019 – June 2021, does EWMA-Normal still have more exceedances than GARCH-t?
                                    Answer

                                    No: EWMA-Normal has 28, GARCH-t 32, against 25.3 expected. The 5% quantile of the standardised t with ν = 6.26 is −1.59, closer to zero than the −1.645 of the Normal distribution: heavy tails require larger quantiles only far in the tail. At VaR 1%: 13 GARCH-t and 17 EWMA-Normal exceedances (5 expected); at 0.5%: 7 and 16.

                                    Daily log returns in %, up to 18 September 2026: S&P 500, BET and Bitcoin from the market data of the course (EODHD), EUR/RON from the BNR reference rate. The GARCH, GJR and EGARCH estimates are those of the lecture; the conditional volatilities are recomputed in the browser from the estimated parameters. Variants with parameters other than the estimates (α, β, λ, the VaR level, the interval coverage) use fixed parameters, not re-estimated. The simulated series use the Normal draws of the chapter’s seed; variants that do not appear in the lecture (other values of α, β or n) are extra runs of the chapter code with the same seed.