Modelling Financial Markets

Chapter 19 · Review and Project Presentations

The slide of the lecture is on the left, the same figure on the right, computed in the browser from the same data. The ▶ button moves the parameter step by step.

Integrated Case Study: BET · Integrated Case Studies: Portfolio, Bitcoin, Romanian Investor · Case Study: Nonstandard Errors

Integrated Case Study: BET

Step 1: Stylised Facts of the BET

Slide 38: Step 1: Stylised Facts of the BET
Slide 38
    Question for the room The Hill tail index of BET losses is 2.39. What does this value say about the kurtosis of the returns?
    Answer

    For a Pareto-type tail with true index α < 4, the fourth moment is infinite. The Hill estimate of 2.39 and its 95% confidence interval [2.12, 3.03] support this interpretation without proving it. If this tail assumption is correct, the sample excess kurtosis of 11.1 does not estimate a finite parameter; this is why the tail index is reported. The threshold 2 concerns the second moment; the relevant threshold for the fourth moment is 4. Over the full sample, 51 days lie beyond ±4 standard deviations, against 0.42 expected under the Normal distribution.

    Step 2: GARCH(1,1)-t Volatility

    Slide 40: Step 2: GARCH(1,1)-t Volatility
    Slide 40
      Question for the room In GARCH(1,1), the effect of a shock on the variance forecast is carried forward by the factor α + β = 0.9907 per day. After approximately how many days is this effect halved?
      Answer

      After about 74 trading days: ln 0.5 / ln 0.9907. Using β = 0.799 alone ignores the propagation through future shocks; 1/(1 − p) is not the half-life formula. The persistence cannot be bounded away from 1: the likelihood-ratio test of p = 1 gives LR = 1.01, with p-value 0.16. The profile interval for p, [0.975, 1], maps to a half-life interval with a lower end of about 27 days and no finite upper end.

      Step 3: Losses and VaR 1%, 2020–2026

      Slide 41: Step 3: Losses and VaR 1%, 2020–2026
      Slide 41
        Question for the room Over the 1,675 days of 2020–2026, about 17 breaches of the VaR 1% were expected. Which of the two models comes close to this number?
        Answer

        FHS, with 22 breaches; the Normal model has 41. The FHS VaR rose to 11.6% on 18 Mar 2020, while the Normal VaR, estimated on 500 days, adjusts slowly and its breaches cluster in the first weeks of every stress episode.

        Step 4: Breach Rates

        Slide 42: Step 4: Breach Rates
        Slide 42
          Question for the room VaR 1%, 5,432 evaluation days: read separately, the 5% Kupiec tests reject HS, the Normal model and GARCH-t. Does the list of rejected models change if we apply the Holm correction (FWER 5%) to the four tests?
          Answer

          No. The Kupiec p-values are below 0.001 (Normal, 122 breaches), 0.001 (GARCH-t, 80), 0.002 (HS, 79) and 0.095 (FHS, 67). Holm compares them, in order, with 0.05/4 = 0.0125, 0.05/3 ≈ 0.0167, 0.05/2 = 0.025 and 0.05: the first three pass, FHS does not. The correction makes the tests stricter, so it cannot add rejections. The FHS rate, 1.23%, lies inside the 95% binomial band [0.74%, 1.27%]; the non-rejection does not establish that the true rate is exactly 1%. A rate above 1% does not imply rejection, and numerical closeness to 1% does not replace the test.

          How Much Can a Backtest Detect? The Power of Kupiec

          Slide 45: How Much Can a Backtest Detect? The Power of Kupiec
          Slide 45
            Question for the room Assume independent breaches with a true daily probability of 2% for a VaR 1% model. How does the probability that the 5% Kupiec test rejects the model change when ▶ increases T from 250 to 5,432 days?
            Answer

            It rises from 24% to almost 100% (78% at T = 1,000). At T = 250 the test rejects at 0 breaches or at 7 or more. The 5% level is nominal and concerns the null; 1 − 5% is not the power either. With the asymptotic critical value 3.84, the actual rejection probability at the null rate of 1% is 9.5% at T = 250. On the page grid, the first true rate detected with at least 80% power is 3.65% at T = 250 (an excess of 2.65 percentage points over the target), 2.05% at T = 1,000 and 1.45% at T = 5,432. A non-rejection with low power means “no evidence”, not “no problem”.

            Integrated Case Studies: Portfolio, Bitcoin, Romanian Investor

            Multi-Asset Portfolio: Weights, VaR and Risk Contributions

            Slide 47: Multi-Asset Portfolio: Weights, VaR and Risk Contributions
            Slide 47
              Question for the room Which mechanism can contribute to DCC-FHS understating risk, although DCC-FHS and DCC-Normal use the same conditional covariance?
              Answer

              The FHS history reuses the data on which the GMV weights were optimised, which can make the historical risk too small: the mean standard deviation of the standardised portfolio returns across the FHS windows is 0.91, while the standard deviation of the out-of-sample standardised returns is 0.95. FHS multiplies the empirical quantile of the standardised losses by the current volatility: the mean VaR is 0.55%, against 0.58% for DCC-Normal. DCC-FHS has 52 breaches against 35.8 expected (Kupiec p 0.011); DCC-Normal has 40 breaches and passes all three tests. These results support the diagnosis without isolating the contribution of each mechanism. The comparison is retrospective: the VaR model is chosen on the same period on which it is evaluated.

              Bitcoin: Bubbles, Realised-Volatility VaR and Liquidity

              Slide 51: Bitcoin: Bubbles, Realised-Volatility VaR and Liquidity
              Slide 51
                Question for the room The evaluation has 422 days. How often would the 5% Kupiec test reject a VaR 1% model whose true breach rate is 2%?
                Answer

                Only with probability 47%; the minimum detectable effect at 80% power is 2.70%. Both models have 7 breaches against 4.2 expected (p = 0.214), so the practical difference is capital: a mean VaR of 5.29% for log-HAR, against 6.24% for HS.

                A Romanian Investor: Efficiency, Currency Hedging and ES in Lei

                Slide 55: A Romanian Investor: Efficiency, Currency Hedging and ES in Lei
                Slide 55
                  Question for the room In the retrospective comparison for Aug 2008 – Sep 2026, which mechanism can explain why a full currency hedge did not lower the ES of the portfolio?
                  Answer

                  The negative association between the Euro Stoxx 50 return and the EUR/RON change (β = −0.52, t = −2.61) partly offset the losses: when EUR/RON rises, the leu depreciates and the value in lei of the euro investment rises, other things equal. The association is not a rule that holds every week. The EUR/RON volatility is 4.6% a year, against 20.9% for the Euro Stoxx 50. Weekly ES 2.5%, Aug 2008 – Sep 2026: 9.60% unhedged, 9.67% with a full hedge; in Aug 2008 – Dec 2012 the order reverses (15.23% and 15.12%). This retrospective comparison does not replace the decision rule of the lecture, which chooses the full hedge (h = 1).

                  Case Study: Nonstandard Errors

                  A Mini-Multiverse on Course Data: 27 Paths per Index

                  Slide 68: A Mini-Multiverse on Course Data: 27 Paths per Index
                  Slide 68
                    Question for the room Over all 27 paths, the IQR of the Euro Stoxx 50 estimates is 64.6 pp. ▶ restricts the grid, in turn, to a single model of the yearly change. What does the IQR of the nine linear-trend paths become?
                    Answer

                    About 2.6 pp (BET: 6.7 pp, against 82.6 pp over the full grid). With relative differences, the medians are +98.7% and +80.3% a year: the model of the yearly change separates the distributions of the estimates the most. The sampling benchmark, 1.35 × the median SE, is 41.3 pp over the full grid and 3.9 pp for the nine linear-trend paths. The comparison is descriptive, not an estimate of the share of dispersion due to each choice.

                    BET index: official daily closing values, 6 Jan 2000 – 18 Sep 2026, log returns in %. One-day VaR forecasts: rolling window of 1,000 days (500 for HS and the Normal model), GARCH re-estimated every 21 days, evaluation from 3 Jan 2005. Mini-multiverse: daily closes of the Euro Stoxx 50 (EODHD) and the BET, 2002–2018. Integrated case studies: eight multi-asset ETFs (adjusted prices, 2007–2026), Bitcoin (daily closes 2014–2026, 5-minute bars 2024–2026), the BET, the Euro Stoxx 50 and the BNR EUR/RON reference rate (2005–2026).