Modelling Financial Markets

Chapter 2 · Market Efficiency

The slide of the lecture is on the left, the same figure on the right, computed in the browser from the same data. The ▶ button moves the parameter step by step.

Returns and Information · Autocorrelation and Variance Ratios · Out-of-Sample Predictability · Event Studies · Multiple Testing and Anomalies · Case Study: Time-Series Momentum in Bitcoin

Returns and Information

A Real Price Series among Simulated Random Walks

Slide 4: A Real Price Series among Simulated Random Walks
Slide 4
    Question for the room One of the four series is the S&P 500 from 2010 to 2026; the other three are random walks with the same drift and volatility. All four paths show trends and sharp falls. What can we infer from these features alone?
    Answer

    A random walk with drift can produce trends, and Normal innovations can produce large moves. These visual features alone do not constitute a statistical rejection. The real series is D; recognising it does not establish return predictability. This is why efficiency is tested with statistics rather than by inspection.

    Three models for returns and volatility

    Slide 12: Three models for returns and volatility
    Slide 12
      Question for the room RW2 has independent returns, with standard deviation 1% up to day 450 and 3% after; GARCH has turbulent periods after large shocks. What is the kurtosis of RW2 in this simulation?
      Answer

      Clearly above 3: 4.8, against 3.0 for RW1 and 4.1 for GARCH. Mixing a calm period with a turbulent one gives fat tails without any dependence, so neither the chart of returns nor the kurtosis tells RW2 from GARCH. The difference lies elsewhere: in RW2 volatility rises at a date fixed in advance and the returns stay independent; in GARCH today's volatility depends on yesterday's shock (α = 0.08) and on yesterday's volatility (β = 0.90), so the returns are dependent.

      GARCH: returns versus squared returns

      Slide 13: GARCH: returns versus squared returns
      Slide 13
        Question for the room Keep β = 0.90 and the 900-day series. As α rises from 0.08 to 0.095, how does the sample lag-1 autocorrelation of squared returns change?
        Answer

        It rises: in this simulation, the sample autocorrelation rises from 0.216 to 0.272. A long-run variance of 1 does not fix the dependence of squared returns. At α = 0.095, 3α² + 2αβ + β² equals 1.0081: the stationary model has no finite fourth moment, so the theoretical ACF of squared returns is undefined. The sample ACF of the finite series can still be calculated. At α = 0 the returns are independent: the sample autocorrelation of the squares is 0.049 at lag 1 and goes down to −0.050 over lags 1–20. For α > 0 the series satisfies RW3 but violates RW2: the size of today's move depends on past shocks.

        Autocorrelation and Variance Ratios

        Lag-1 Autocorrelation Across Markets

        Slide 17: Lag-1 Autocorrelation Across Markets
        Slide 17
          Question for the room In a hypothetical example, the estimated autocorrelation is −0.040, the i.i.d. standard error is 0.012, and the robust standard error under H₀ is 0.027. Using the asymptotic two-sided cutoff of 1.96, which test rejects H₀: ρ₁ = 0?
          Answer

          Only the test using the i.i.d. standard error. With the i.i.d. standard error, |z| = 0.040/0.012 = 3.33; with the robust error, |z| = 0.040/0.027 = 1.48. The decision depends on the estimate relative to its standard error, not on the autocorrelation's magnitude alone. For the S&P 500, ρ̂₁ = −0.099 lies outside both test bands, with the same standard errors (0.027 robust, 0.012 i.i.d.); for the Euro Stoxx 50 or the Nikkei 225, ρ̂₁ falls outside the i.i.d. band but inside the robust one. The bars around the estimates are confidence intervals with the HAC standard error of the estimator (S&P 500: 0.030); they serve for comparisons, not for the test of ρ₁ = 0.

          Variance-Ratio Profiles

          Slide 23: Variance-Ratio Profiles
          Slide 23
            Question for the room For the S&P 500, the 20-day variance ratio is 0.754. For this value, what is the standard-error boundary below which |(VR − 1)/SE| exceeds 1.96?
            Answer

            The boundary is |0.754 − 1|/1.96 = 0.1255. The value 0.2460 is the deviation from the null before division by the cutoff. The value 0.1328 is the actual robust standard error at 20 days; it exceeds the boundary, so the test does not reject. The null band widens with q: its lower edge is 0.817 at 10 days, where VR = 0.767 is rejected, and 0.740 at 20 days. The calculation uses overlapping aggregated returns and the robust Lo–MacKinlay standard error.

            Out-of-Sample Predictability

            The Dividend–Price Ratio: Out-of-Sample Forecasts

            Slide 31: The Dividend–Price Ratio: Out-of-Sample Forecasts
            Slide 31
              Question for the room Over 680 monthly forecasts from 1970, R²OS is −0.51%. Does it turn positive if the evaluation starts later?
              Answer

              No. For every start between 1970 and 2015, R²OS stays negative: −1.37% from 1990, −0.01% from 2000, −2.75% from 2010. The curve rises until 1990, and the 1990s boom wipes out the advantage. The Clark–West test over 1970–2026 gives t = 0.42 (p = 0.34), so the absence of predictability is not rejected.

              Event Studies

              Worked Example: the Romanian Bank Tax of December 2018

              Slide 40: Worked Example: the Romanian Bank Tax of December 2018
              Slide 40
                Question for the room TLV's CAR[0,5] is −1.1%, and its estimated beta is 1.18. Keep TLV returns, alpha and beta unchanged, but increase the sum of BET log returns over the window by 1 percentage point. What is TLV's new CAR?
                Answer

                CAR falls by 1.18 × 1 percentage point because the benchmark return is subtracted after multiplication by beta: −1.1% − 1.18% = −2.28%. The +0.08% option reverses the adjustment's sign. The −1.1% option ignores the benchmark. CAR can change without any change in TLV prices. In the data, AR₀ = −8.3% and the CAR over days +1 to +5 is +7.2% (t = 3.82), although over days 0 to +5 the log return is −15.6% for TLV and −12.7% for the BET. The test for CAR[0,5] gives t = −0.48 with the prediction error and t = −0.54 with σ̂√L. A single event cannot separate overreaction, later news and a benchmark effect.

                Multiple Testing and Anomalies

                How Many “Anomalies” Does Pure Chance Produce?

                Slide 48: How Many “Anomalies” Does Pure Chance Produce?
                Slide 48
                  Question for the room For 2,000 tests with valid p-values, which individual Bonferroni cutoff guarantees at most a 5% probability of any false rejection, regardless of dependence between tests?
                  Answer

                  The cutoff is 0.05/2,000 = 0.000025. The value 0.025 divides the level by two rather than by the number of tests; a two-sided p-value already includes both tails. The value 0.05 retains the individual level without controlling the family. Bonferroni's guarantee does not require independent tests. In the simulation, of 2,000 rules with no economic content, 104 (5.2%) have |t| > 1.96, six have |t| > 3.0, and the best has |t| = 3.30. Adding rules to the same family cannot lower the largest |t|.

                  Case Study: Time-Series Momentum in Bitcoin

                  Bitcoin: The Momentum Slope in the Paper's Sample and After

                  Slide 67: Bitcoin: The Momentum Slope in the Paper's Sample and After
                  Slide 67
                    Question for the room After May 2018, Bitcoin's slope is b₁ = 0.115, with NW t = 2.61. Which conclusion does this regression support?
                    Answer

                    The regression supports a one-week predictive association. A one-standard-deviation increase in the current return corresponds to an estimated 0.96-percentage-point increase in next week's return, compared with 2.98 percentage points in the earlier period. Neither a trading rule after costs nor out-of-sample forecast errors are evaluated. Using a sample after the paper's sample period does not replace that evaluation. Over rolling two-year windows, b₁ is significant in 13% of the windows.

                    Stock indices, Bitcoin, Ethereum, TLV, BRD and BET: EODHD daily prices up to 18 September 2026. EUR/RON: the NBR reference rate. Monthly S&P 500 with dividends: Robert J. Shiller's public data, extended with daily S&P 500 prices; 3-month Treasury bill rate from FRED (TB3MS).