Statistics of Financial Markets

Chapter 2 · Classical Distributions and Stylised Facts

The slide of the lecture is on the left, the same figure on the right, computed in the browser from the same data. The ▶ button moves the parameter step by step.

The Normal Distribution · The Lognormal Distribution · The Central Limit Theorem · Moments and the Shape of a Distribution · Testing Normality: Jarque–Bera and QQ Plots · The Student-t Distribution · Stylised Facts of Returns

The Normal Distribution

The 68–95–99.7 Rule

Slide 11: The 68–95–99.7 Rule
Slide 11
    Question for the room Under the Normal distribution, a day beyond 3 standard deviations occurs once in 370 days. The ▶ button moves the threshold up to 6. How many times rarer is a day beyond 4 standard deviations?
    Answer

    About 43 times. P(|Z| > 4) = 0.0063%, one day in 15,787, about 63 years of trading at 252 days a year; P(|Z| > 3) = 0.27%, one day in 370. The ratio of the densities at 3 and 4, φ(3)/φ(4) = 33, is not the ratio of the tail probabilities. At 6 standard deviations, the Normal distribution gives one day in 507 million.

    Frequency of Large Moves under the Normal Distribution

    Slide 12: Frequency of Large Moves under the Normal Distribution
    Slide 12

    Normal distribution: P(|Z| > k) and how often such a day occurs; the observed days of the chosen series

    Share of days within k standard deviations of the mean (the 68–95–99.7 rule)

      Question for the room Under the Normal distribution, 68.27% of the days lie within one standard deviation of the mean. What share of S&P 500 days, 2010–2026, lies within one standard deviation of the mean?
      Answer

      79.1%, more than under the Normal distribution. A few extreme days inflate the standard deviation, and most days are small relative to it: the centre of the distribution is taller. Within two standard deviations the share is 95.3%, close to 95.45%; beyond three standard deviations there are 62 days instead of 11.3. For the eight series, the share within one standard deviation is between 75.7% (BRD) and 81.4% (BET).

      Worked Example: Large Losses of the S&P 500

      Slide 13: Worked Example: Large Losses of the S&P 500
      Slide 13

      Days with a log return below −x%: observed and expected under the Normal distribution

      Worked example: losses larger than x%

      \[z = \frac{-x - \bar r}{s}, \qquad P(r_t < -x) = \Phi(z), \qquad E = n\,\Phi(z)\]
          Question for the room The S&P 500 has 49 days below −3%, against 10.5 expected under the Normal distribution with the same mean and standard deviation. For Bitcoin, with the same threshold of −3%, are there more or fewer such days than the series’ Normal distribution expects?
          Answer

          Fewer: 512 days, against 813 expected. Bitcoin’s standard deviation is 3.49%, so −3% is only 0.89 standard deviations below the mean, between the centre and the tail, where heavy-tailed returns have fewer days than the Normal distribution. Heavy tails show at thresholds of several standard deviations: below −10% (2.90 standard deviations), Bitcoin has 56 days, against 8.1 expected. A threshold in % compares series only when their volatilities are similar.

          The Lognormal Distribution

          Lognormal Densities (SFElognormal)

          Slide 17: Lognormal Densities (SFElognormal)
          Slide 17
            Question for the room The ▶ button raises s from 0.1 to 1.5. What happens to the mode, the median and the mean of the lognormal distribution LN(0, s²)?
            Answer

            The median stays at 1, because em does not depend on s. The mean es²/2 rises to 3.08 and the mode e−s² falls to 0.105. At s = 1, the mean is 1.65, the mode 0.37 and the skewness 6.18. The gap between mean and median grows with volatility and with the horizon, through s = σ√T.

            Worked Example: 100 Lei in the BET

            Slide 18: Worked Example: 100 Lei in the BET
            Slide 18

            Value of 100 lei invested, PT/P0 ~ LN(Tμ, Tσ²)

            Worked example: the value of 100 lei after T years

            \[\begin{gathered}\frac{P_T}{P_0} \sim LN\big(T\mu,\ T\sigma^2\big):\quad \text{median} = 100\,e^{T\mu}, \quad \text{mean} = 100\,e^{T\mu + T\sigma^2/2},\\ P(P_T < P_0) = \Phi\Big(-\frac{\mu\sqrt{T}}{\sigma}\Big), \qquad q_\alpha = 100\,e^{T\mu + z_\alpha\,\sigma\sqrt{T}}\end{gathered}\]
                Question for the room For 100 lei invested in the BET, the probability of a loss is 24.8% after one year and 1.5% after ten years. The ▶ button raises the horizon up to 20 years. What is the probability of a loss after 20 years?
                Answer

                0.11%: Φ(−μ√T/σ) = Φ(−0.682 × √20) = Φ(−3.05). The mean of the log return grows with T and its standard deviation with √T, so the ratio μ√T/σ grows with √T. The median becomes 1,009.6 and the mean 1,345.6: the gap between them widens with the horizon. The calculation assumes that the mean log return of 2010–2026, 11.6% a year, persists and that log returns are Normal and independent; for the S&P 500 the same calculation gives 0.15%, for Bitcoin 0.19%.

                The Central Limit Theorem

                Illustration of the CLT (SFEclt)

                Slide 22: Illustration of the CLT (SFEclt)
                Slide 22

                Worked example: the exact binomial distribution of the mean

                \[\begin{gathered}Z_n = \frac{\bar X_n - p}{\sqrt{p(1-p)/n}} = \frac{S_n - np}{\sqrt{np(1-p)}}, \qquad S_n \sim \text{Bin}(n, p),\\ P(Z_n > 1.96) = \sum_{j > np + 1.96\sqrt{np(1-p)}} \binom{n}{j} p^j (1-p)^{n-j}\end{gathered}\]
                    Question for the room On the slide p = 0.2, and the skewness of the standardised mean is 0.27 for n = 30. The ▶ button lowers p from 0.5 to 0.02. With p = 0.02, is the skewness for n = 300 below 0.27?
                    Answer

                    No. The skewness of the mean is (1 − 2p)/√(np(1 − p)) = 0.96/√5.88 = 0.40 for n = 300 and p = 0.02, above the 0.27 for n = 30 and p = 0.2. The skewness falls as 1/√n, but from a level that depends on p: the further p is from 0.5, the more draws are needed. The page computes the exact distribution of the mean; the share above 1.96 for p = 0.2 is 5.8%, 2.6% and 2.8% (n = 5, 30, 300), and in the 20,000 simulations of the slide 5.8%, 2.7% and 2.8%.

                    The Normal Approximation of the Binomial (SFENormalApprox)

                    Slide 23: The Normal Approximation of the Binomial (SFENormalApprox)
                    Slide 23
                      Question for the room With p = 0.1, the ▶ button raises n from 5 to 200. The rule of thumb asks for np(1 − p) of at least about 9, that is n = 100. Does the largest CDF error fall below 0.01 by n = 200?
                      Answer

                      No. With the continuity correction, the largest CDF error is 0.037 at n = 20, 0.017 at n = 100 and 0.012 at n = 200. The rule np(1 − p) ≥ 9 says where the approximation becomes usable, not a guaranteed accuracy; the error falls slowly, roughly as 1/√n, with small oscillations from one n to the next. Without the continuity correction, the error at n = 20 is 0.177.

                      Moments and the Shape of a Distribution

                      Skewness and Kurtosis: Graphical Illustration

                      Slide 27: Skewness and Kurtosis: Graphical Illustration
                      Slide 27
                        Question for the room On the slide, the shape parameter α = 5 gives a skew-Normal density with skewness 0.85. The ▶ button raises α from 0 to 20 (and lowers ν from 40 to 4.5 in the left panel). What is the skewness of the density at α = 20?
                        Answer

                        0.99. The skewness of the skew-Normal family grows with α but has a limit of about 0.995: at α = 10 it is 0.96, at α = 20 it is 0.99. A larger skewness cannot be obtained with this family. The excess kurtosis of the unit-variance Student-t distribution is 6/(ν − 4): 6 for ν = 5, 1 for ν = 10.

                        Daily Log Returns: Moments, 2010–2026

                        Slide 29: Daily Log Returns: Moments, 2010–2026
                        Slide 29

                        Daily log returns (%): moments

                        Worked example: skewness and excess kurtosis from real returns

                        \[m_k = \frac1n\sum_{t=1}^{n}(r_t-\bar r)^k, \qquad S = \frac{m_3}{m_2^{3/2}}, \qquad K = \frac{m_4}{m_2^2} - 3, \qquad \text{SE}(S) = \sqrt{6/n},\ \ \text{SE}(K) = \sqrt{24/n}\]
                            Question for the room Without the period 20 February–30 April 2020, the excess kurtosis of the S&P 500 falls from 13.5 to 5.4. What happens to the excess kurtosis of the BET?
                            Answer

                            It stays at 18.0 (17.9 on the full sample). The worst BET day, −11.9% on 19 December 2018 (OUG 114, a tax on bank assets), lies outside this period. The sample kurtosis depends on the few extreme days of each series, and these differ from market to market. Without this period, Bitcoin falls from 12.0 to 5.4 and the DAX from 7.4 to 3.1.

                            DAX Returns vs the Normal Density (SFEDaxReturnDistribution)

                            Slide 30: DAX Returns vs the Normal Density (SFEDaxReturnDistribution)
                            Slide 30
                              Question for the room At −6%, the estimated density of DAX returns is 439 times the Normal density, with the bandwidth given by Scott’s rule. What happens to this ratio if the bandwidth is halved?
                              Answer

                              It rises to about 580; at a quarter of Scott’s bandwidth it reaches 1,100, and at twice the bandwidth it is 522. There are few observations in the tail, and the density estimate there depends on the bandwidth. For every bandwidth tried, the ratio stays in the hundreds: the conclusion that the DAX has much heavier tails than the Normal distribution does not depend on this choice. The peak of the estimated density falls from 0.47 to 0.34 as the bandwidth rises from 0.5 to 3 times Scott’s rule.

                              Testing Normality: Jarque–Bera and QQ Plots

                              Worked Example: Jarque–Bera for the S&P 500

                              Slide 34: Worked Example: Jarque–Bera for the S&P 500
                              Slide 34

                              Jarque–Bera test, daily log returns

                              Worked example: the Jarque–Bera statistic step by step

                              \[\text{JB} = \frac{n}{6}\Big(S^2 + \frac{K^2}{4}\Big) \;\overset{H_0}{\sim}\; \chi^2(2), \qquad p = P\big(\chi^2(2) > \text{JB}\big) = e^{-\text{JB}/2}\]
                                  Question for the room The ▶ button moves the start of the sample up to 2024, when each series has only 600 to 1,000 days. Does the Jarque–Bera test still reject normality at 5% for all eight series?
                                  Answer

                                  Yes. From 2024, the smallest JB is 33, for SNP (n = 632, S = −0.03, K = 1.1), above the critical value 5.99; the S&P 500 still has 6,318, with K = 14.9, from the days of April 2025. With several hundred observations, an excess kurtosis of about 1 already gives a JB far above 5.99. Over 2010–2026, JB is between 3,174 (SNN) and 56,762 (BET).

                                  QQ Plots against the Normal Distribution

                                  Slide 37: QQ Plots against the Normal Distribution
                                  Slide 37
                                    Question for the room The ▶ button moves the start of the sample from 2010 to 2024. If the sample starts in 2021, after March 2020, does the smallest standardised S&P 500 return still lie beyond the corresponding Normal quantile?
                                    Answer

                                    Yes. Since the start of 2021, the smallest S&P 500 return is −6.2%, on 4 April 2025: −6.0 standard deviations, against the Normal quantile −3.4. Over the whole sample, 16 March 2020 gives −11.8 against −3.7. March 2020 makes the deviation larger but does not create it: BET (−6.1) and Bitcoin (−5.8) also stay far from the line after 2021.

                                    The Student-t Distribution

                                    Student-t Densities with Unit Variance

                                    Slide 42: Student-t Densities with Unit Variance
                                    Slide 42
                                      Question for the room With ν = 5 and unit variance, a day beyond 4 standard deviations is 56 times more likely than under the Normal distribution. The ▶ button raises the threshold up to 6. What happens to this ratio?
                                      Answer

                                      It rises: 2,316 at 5 standard deviations and about 290,000 at 6. The Student-t tail decays as a power, |x|−ν, and the Normal tail as e−x²/2, so the ratio grows without bound. At 6 standard deviations, P(|X| > 6) is 0.057% for t(5) and 0.0000002% for the Normal distribution.

                                      Fitted Student-t: Degrees of Freedom, 2010–2026

                                      Slide 44: Fitted Student-t: Degrees of Freedom, 2010–2026
                                      Slide 44

                                      Student-t fitted by maximum likelihood

                                      Worked example: the variance ν/(ν − 2) and the tail probability of the fitted t

                                      \[\text{Var}(X) = s^2\,\frac{\nu}{\nu-2}\ \ (\nu > 2), \qquad P\big(|X - \mu| > c\big) = 2\,F_{t(\nu)}\Big(-\frac{c}{s}\Big)\]
                                          Question for the room With the sample from 2010, ν̂ is below 4 for 7 of the 8 series. The ▶ button moves the start of the sample. If the sample starts in 2021, for how many series is ν̂ below 4?
                                          Answer

                                          For 3: BET (3.76), Bitcoin (2.69) and SNN (3.03). The S&P 500 moves from 2.78 to 4.05, BRD from 4.67 to 6.26. Without 2020 the tails are thinner, but every ν̂ stays between 2.7 and 6.3, far from the Normal distribution (ν → ∞), and ΔAIC still favours the t distribution for every series (at least 66, for SNP). ν̂ is an estimate that depends on the sample, above all on the few extreme days it contains.

                                          S&P 500: Normal vs Student-t Fit

                                          Slide 45: S&P 500: Normal vs Student-t Fit
                                          Slide 45
                                            Question for the room The ▶ button fixes ν at values from 2.2 to 30 and re-estimates the location and scale for the S&P 500. Which value gives the higher log-likelihood: ν = 2.2 or ν = 4?
                                            Answer

                                            ν = 2.2: the log-likelihood is −5,704.8, against −5,714.6 at ν = 4. The maximum, −5,693.8, is at the estimate ν̂ = 2.78, and the profile is not symmetric around it: it falls slowly towards small ν and faster towards large ν. At ν = 30 the log-likelihood is −6,054.5, towards −6,301.2, the value of the Normal distribution. The AIC difference between the Normal and the t distribution is 12,606.4 − 11,393.6 = 1,212.8 in favour of the t distribution.

                                            QQ Plots against the Fitted Student-t

                                            Slide 46: QQ Plots against the Fitted Student-t
                                            Slide 46
                                              Question for the room With the estimated ν (2.78), the t distribution predicts a minimum of −15.8% for the S&P 500, below the observed minimum of −12.8%. The ▶ button fixes ν at larger values. For which ν does the predicted minimum come close to the observed one?
                                              Answer

                                              Between ν = 3 and ν = 4. With the location and scale re-estimated, the predicted minimum is −13.6% at ν = 3 and −8.7% at ν = 4, against −12.8% observed. A larger ν means thinner tails. At ν = 4 the centre fits as well, but the observed extremes again fall below the line; no single value of ν fits the centre and the extremes at the same time.

                                              Stylised Facts of Returns

                                              Fact 1: Heavy Tails, Number of k-Sigma Days

                                              Slide 51: Fact 1: Heavy Tails, Number of k-Sigma Days
                                              Slide 51

                                              Days with |rt − r̄| > k s

                                              Worked example: P(|Z| > k), the expected number of days and the Poisson p-value

                                              \[p_k = P(|Z| > k) = 2\big(1 - \Phi(k)\big), \qquad \lambda = n\,p_k, \qquad P(N \ge N_{\text{obs}}) = 1 - \sum_{j=0}^{N_{\text{obs}}-1} e^{-\lambda}\frac{\lambda^j}{j!}\]
                                                  Question for the room At 4σ, the S&P 500 has 28 days, against 0.27 expected: Poisson p-value 2 × 10⁻⁴⁶. At 3σ it has 62 days, against 11.3 expected. Is the p-value at 3σ larger or smaller than at 4σ?
                                                  Answer

                                                  Larger: 1 × 10⁻²⁵. More days are observed at 3σ, but the ratio to the expected number is 5.5 instead of 105, and the p-value depends on how far the observed count lies from λ relative to the spread of the Poisson distribution. Both values are far below any usual level. At 5σ and 6σ, the S&P 500 p-values are 8 × 10⁻⁴¹ and 6 × 10⁻⁴⁶.

                                                  Fact 1: 4-Sigma Days in Every Market

                                                  Slide 52: Fact 1: 4-Sigma Days in Every Market
                                                  Slide 52
                                                    Question for the room At 4 standard deviations, the S&P 500 has 28 days, against 0.27 expected under the Normal distribution. The ▶ button raises the threshold up to 6. How many days beyond 6 standard deviations does the S&P 500 have?
                                                    Answer

                                                    8 days, against 0.0000083 expected (one day in 507 million). BET has 11, DAX 4, Bitcoin 4. The ratio of observed to expected days grows with the threshold: 5.5 at 3 standard deviations, 105 at 4, about one million at 6.

                                                    Fact 2: Aggregational Gaussianity

                                                    Slide 53: Fact 2: Aggregational Gaussianity
                                                    Slide 53

                                                    h-day log returns, non-overlapping blocks, from 2010

                                                      Question for the room At h = 63 days (quarters, 46 to 69 returns per series), for how many of the eight series does the Jarque–Bera test reject normality at 5%?
                                                      Answer

                                                      For 2: S&P 500 (p-value 0.00004) and DAX (0.002). For the other six, the p-value is between 0.07 (BET) and 0.71 (SNG). At h = 21 the test still rejects for 7 series, all except BRD (0.16). Not rejecting does not show that quarterly returns are Normal: with fewer than 70 observations, the test has little power.

                                                      Fact 2: Kurtosis Falls with the Horizon

                                                      Slide 54: Fact 2: Kurtosis Falls with the Horizon
                                                      Slide 54
                                                        Question for the room The excess kurtosis of daily S&P 500 returns is 13.5. What does it become if we remove the period 20 February–30 April 2020, that is 50 of the 4,201 days?
                                                        Answer

                                                        About 5.4. The monthly excess kurtosis (h = 21) falls from 3.7 to 0.8. The fourth moment depends heavily on a few extreme values: 50 days, 1.2% of the sample, account for more than half of the daily excess kurtosis. Even without them, daily returns are not Normal: 5.4 is far above 0.

                                                        Fact 2: S&P 500, Daily vs Monthly QQ Plots

                                                        Slide 55: Fact 2: S&P 500, Daily vs Monthly QQ Plots
                                                        Slide 55
                                                          Question for the room At h = 63 days (a quarter, n = 66), does the Jarque–Bera test still reject normality of S&P 500 returns at 5%?
                                                          Answer

                                                          Yes: p-value 0.00004, with skewness −1.13 and excess kurtosis 1.5. For BET (p-value 0.07) and Bitcoin (0.22), the test no longer rejects at this horizon. Not rejecting does not show that quarterly returns are Normal: with 66 observations, the test has little power.

                                                          Facts 3 and 4: ACF of Returns and of Absolute Returns

                                                          Slide 57: Facts 3 and 4: ACF of Returns and of Absolute Returns
                                                          Slide 57
                                                            Question for the room Over the full sample, ρ̂(1) of S&P 500 returns is −0.11, and the 95% band is ±0.03. What is ρ̂(1) without the period 20 February–30 April 2020?
                                                            Answer

                                                            −0.04, close to the edge of the ±0.03 band. Most of the −0.11 comes from March 2020, when large falls and rebounds alternated. The autocorrelations of absolute returns stay large without this period too. The power δ shows the same for |rt|δ: for the S&P 500, the autocorrelation at lag 10 is 0.20 for δ = 0.5, 0.26 for δ = 1 and 0.22 for δ = 2.

                                                            Fact 3: Weak Autocorrelation of Returns

                                                            Slide 58: Fact 3: Weak Autocorrelation of Returns
                                                            Slide 58

                                                            Ljung–Box test for returns and for absolute returns

                                                              Question for the room With m = 10, the Ljung–Box test rejects the absence of autocorrelation of returns at 5% for all eight series (Bitcoin: Q = 20.2, p-value 0.028). Without the period 20 February–30 April 2020, for how many series does it still reject?
                                                              Answer

                                                              For 6: Bitcoin (p-value 0.053) and BRD (0.059) no longer reject. For the S&P 500, Q(10) falls from 199 to 32. The χ² distribution of Q assumes i.i.d. returns; with volatility clustering the test rejects too often, so “significant” is a weak conclusion here. For absolute returns, Q(10) stays between 325 and 1,712 for every series.

                                                              Fact 4: Calm and Turbulent Periods

                                                              Slide 60: Fact 4: Calm and Turbulent Periods
                                                              Slide 60
                                                                Question for the room With a 63-day window (a quarter), how many times larger is the largest rolling standard deviation of the S&P 500 than the smallest?
                                                                Answer

                                                                About 12 times: 3.94% a day in the window ending on 20 May 2020, against 0.32% in the window ending on 13 December 2017. The ratio of the variances is about 154. For BET the ratio of standard deviations is 8.2, for Bitcoin 8.3. The volatility of a day depends on the period it falls in.

                                                                Fact 5: Leverage Correlations

                                                                Slide 62: Fact 5: Leverage Correlations
                                                                Slide 62
                                                                  Question for the room The ▶ button moves the start of the sample from 2010 to 2022. If the sample starts in 2021, does the mean L(1..5) of the S&P 500 stay negative and outside the 95% band?
                                                                  Answer

                                                                  Yes. Since the start of 2021, the mean L(1..5) of the S&P 500 is −0.10 (−0.12 over the full sample), and the band is ±0.05. The leverage effect does not come from a single crisis: without 20 February–30 April 2020, the full-sample mean is −0.11. For Bitcoin, the mean stays close to zero in every variant.

                                                                  Fact 6: Gain/Loss Asymmetry

                                                                  Slide 63: Fact 6: Gain/Loss Asymmetry
                                                                  Slide 63
                                                                    Question for the room At 1%, the loss exceeded on one day in 100 is larger than the gain for the S&P 500, DAX, BET and Bitcoin. The ▶ button raises the probability α from 0.1% to 5% and lowers the threshold k of the right panel to the matching Normal quantile. At α = 5%, is the loss larger than the gain for all four indices?
                                                                    Answer

                                                                    No. At 5%, the S&P 500 (1.65% against 1.54%) and the DAX (1.94% against 1.82%) still have the larger loss, but for BET (1.48% against 1.52%) and Bitcoin (5.33% against 5.35%) the gain is slightly larger. The gain/loss asymmetry shows in the far tail; at α = 0.1%, the loss is larger for all four (S&P 500 6.14% against 6.01%).

                                                                    The Six Stylised Facts in Eight Series

                                                                    Slide 64: The Six Stylised Facts in Eight Series
                                                                    Slide 64

                                                                    The statistic of each stylised fact

                                                                      Question for the room Fact 5 is measured by the mean L(1..5) of the leverage correlations; the criterion is a mean below −1.96/√n. On the full sample, for which series is the criterion not met?
                                                                      Answer

                                                                      For SNP (−0.031, against −0.032) and SNN (−0.025, against −0.036). Bitcoin (−0.031, against −0.030) and SNG (−0.039, against −0.036) meet it by a small margin: the four values, between −0.025 and −0.039, are all close to the limit, so fact 5 is equally weak for Bitcoin, SNP, SNN and SNG, while the S&P 500, DAX and BET have −0.10 to −0.12 and BRD −0.05. Fact 6 is not met only for SNN, which has positive skewness (0.27) and |q0.01|/q0.99 = 0.88; SNP (1.04) and SNG (1.02) are close to 1.

                                                                      Daily log returns, in %, from 2010 (Bitcoin from September 2014, SNN and SNG from November 2013) to 18 September 2026. EODHD prices: indices and Bitcoin at the close, BVB stocks adjusted for dividends and corporate actions.