Time Series Analysis

Chapter 14 · Multivariate GARCH Models

The slide of the lecture is on the left, the same figure or table on the right, computed in the browser from the same data. The ▶ button moves the parameter step by step; the “Worked example” boxes redo the calculation with the numbers of the chapter.

Why multivariate volatility · The multivariate GARCH framework · VEC and BEKK models · Constant and dynamic conditional correlations · DCC for the S&P 500 and the DAX · Five markets: S&P 500, DAX, BET, EUR/RON, Bitcoin · Portfolio VaR 1% with DCC · Dynamic hedge ratios

Why multivariate volatility

Worked example: correlation and portfolio risk

Slide 6: Worked example: correlation and portfolio risk
Slide 6

Worked example

\[\sigma_p^2=w_1^2\sigma_1^2+w_2^2\sigma_2^2+2w_1w_2\rho\,\sigma_1\sigma_2,\qquad w_1=w_2=0.5\]
      Question for the room ▶ raises ρ from 0.3 to 1 in steps of 0.1. Does σp rise by the same amount at every step?
      Answer

      No: +0.63 points from ρ = 0.2 to 0.3 (from 15.49% to 16.12%), but only +0.51 points from 0.9 to 1 (from 19.49% to 20%). σp2 is linear in ρ and σp is its square root, so the curve is concave. With ρ = −0.2 the volatility is 12.6%.

      Portfolio volatility against the correlation

      Slide 7: Portfolio volatility against the correlation
      Slide 7
        Question for the room ▶ moves the weight of the first asset from 60% to 90% (both assets at 20%). What happens to σp for ρ = 0.8?
        Answer

        It rises: 19.02% at 60% and 19.64% at 90%, against 18.97% at 50/50. With equal volatilities the 50/50 portfolio has the lowest risk whatever ρ. With the second asset at 40% and ρ = −1, σp = |0.5 · 20 − 0.5 · 40| = 10%: the risk disappears only with w = 2/3.

        Correlations change over time

        Slide 9: Correlations change over time
        Slide 9
          Question for the room ▶ lengthens the window up to 500 days. What happens to the minimum of the S&P 500 – DAX correlation (0.21 at 250 days)?
          Answer

          It rises to 0.30 (November 2025): in a long window the asynchronous days of April 2025 weigh less. With 60 days the correlation goes down to −0.27 (July 2025) and up to 0.86 (January 2012), with a standard deviation of 0.147 against 0.122 at 250 days.

          Asynchronous trading and the bias of daily correlations

          Slide 11: Asynchronous trading and the bias of daily correlations
          Slide 11
            Question for the room ▶ sums the daily returns over k = 2, …, 10 days. What happens to the S&P 500 – BET correlation?
            Answer

            It rises: 0.32 daily, 0.40 over 2 days and 0.50 over 10 days, above the weekly correlation of 0.46: news that reaches Bucharest a day later falls into the same k-day return. Of the ten pairs, only the S&P 500 and Bitcoin have a weekly correlation below the daily one (0.25 → 0.19): the weekly Bitcoin return also contains the weekend, and the 610 weeks give a noisier estimate than the 2,815 days.

            The multivariate GARCH framework

            Two conditions on Hₜ

            Slide 14: Two conditions on Hₜ
            Slide 14

            Worked example

            \[\mathbf{w}^\top\mathbf{H}\mathbf{w}>0\ \ \forall\,\mathbf{w}\neq\mathbf{0}\iff h_{11}>0,\ \ h_{11}h_{22}-h_{12}^2>0,\qquad \rho_{12}=\frac{h_{12}}{\sqrt{h_{11}h_{22}}}\]
                Question for the room ▶ lowers h12 from 2.75 to −3 (h11 = 4, h22 = 1). For which values is H positive definite?
                Answer

                Only for |h12| < 2, i.e. |ρ| < 1. At h12 = ±2 the determinant and one eigenvalue are 0 (a riskless combination); for |h12| > 2 some portfolios have a negative variance, for example −0.416 for h12 = ±2.5. The sign of the covariance does not matter, only its size against √(h11h22).

                VEC and BEKK models

                Worked example: one step of a diagonal BEKK

                Slide 19: Worked example: one step of a diagonal BEKK
                Slide 19

                Worked example

                \[\begin{gathered}h_{12,t}=c_{12}^*+a_{11}a_{22}\,\varepsilon_{1,t-1}\varepsilon_{2,t-1}+b_{11}b_{22}\,h_{12,t-1}\\ c_{12}^*=0.02,\ a_{11}=0.30,\ a_{22}=0.25,\ b_{11}=0.94,\ b_{22}=0.95,\ h_{12,t-1}=0.5\end{gathered}\]
                    Question for the room Set ε2,t−1 = +1.5 (the opposite sign of ε1,t−1 = −2). What is h12,t?
                    Answer

                    0.2415 = 0.020 + 0.075 · (−3) + 0.4465: shocks of opposite signs lower the covariance. With ε2,t−1 = 0, h12,t = 0.4665, still below 0.5, although the long-run level is 0.625: that level accounts for the cross-product of the shocks being equal to h12 on average, and a day without a joint shock brings only the constant and the persistence.

                    The curse of dimensionality

                    Slide 20: The curse of dimensionality
                    Slide 20
                      Question for the room For N = 30, BEKK(1,1) has 2,265 parameters. How many does DCC have?
                      Answer

                      527: 90 GARCH parameters estimated series by series, 435 sample correlations and only 2 parameters, a and b, found by numerical optimisation. VEC(1,1) has 432,915.

                      Parameters against the number of assets

                      Slide 21: Parameters against the number of assets
                      Slide 21
                        Question for the room ▶ raises the largest N up to 100. By what factor does the number of VEC(1,1) parameters grow from N = 50 to N = 100?
                        Answer

                        15.7 times (from 3,252,525 to 51,010,050), like N4: 24 = 16. DCC grows 3.8 times (from 1,377 to 5,252), BEKK(1,1) 4 times (from 6,275 to 25,050).

                        Constant and dynamic conditional correlations

                        Worked example: one step of the DCC recursion

                        Slide 27: Worked example: one step of the DCC recursion
                        Slide 27

                        Worked example

                        \[\begin{gathered}\mathbf{Q}_t=(1-a-b)\,\bar{\mathbf{Q}}+a\,\mathbf{z}_{t-1}\mathbf{z}_{t-1}^\top+b\,\mathbf{Q}_{t-1},\qquad \rho_{12,t}=\frac{q_{12,t}}{\sqrt{q_{11,t}\,q_{22,t}}}\\ \bar q_{12}=0.5,\ \ \mathbf{Q}_{t-1}=\begin{pmatrix}1&0.5\\0.5&1\end{pmatrix},\ \ z_{1,t-1}=-2\end{gathered}\]
                            Question for the room ▶ moves z2,t−1 up to +3, with z1,t−1 = −2. What is ρ12,t for z2,t−1 = +2.5?
                            Answer

                            0.187: q12,t = 0.010 − 0.250 + 0.465 = 0.225, while q11,t = 1.150 and q22,t = 1.2625 stay the same. With z2,t−1 = 0 the correlation is 0.454, still below 0.5: a move of one market alone raises a variance in the denominator without adding anything to the covariance.

                            Reading a and b

                            Slide 28: Reading a and b
                            Slide 28

                            Worked example

                            \[q_{ij,t+k}-\bar q_{ij}\approx(a+b)^k\,(q_{ij,t}-\bar q_{ij}),\qquad \text{half-life}=\frac{\ln 0.5}{\ln(a+b)}\]
                                Question for the room ▶ raises a + b up to 0.995. How does the half-life change from a + b = 0.99 to 0.995?
                                Answer

                                It doubles, from 69 to 138 days: ln(a + b) ≈ −(1 − a − b), so the half-life is about 0.69/(1 − a − b). With a + b = 0.90 it is 6.6 days, and after 20 days 12% of the deviation is left.

                                DCC for the S&P 500 and the DAX

                                Step 1: two univariate GARCH models

                                Slide 30: Step 1: two univariate GARCH models
                                Slide 30
                                  Question for the room Which index loses the larger share of its excess kurtosis after the standardisation?
                                  Answer

                                  The S&P 500: 1 − 1.8/10.5 = 83%, against the DAX: 1 − 1.4/6.2 = 78%. Time-varying volatility explains most of the fat tails, but the residuals zt keep an excess kurtosis of 1.4–1.8; this is why a VaR with the Normal quantile will have too many violations.

                                  Step 1: conditional volatilities

                                  Slide 31: Step 1: conditional volatilities
                                  Slide 31
                                    Question for the room ▶ raises the multiplier of α up to 2 (same persistence). What happens to the 2020 peak of the S&P 500 volatility?
                                    Answer

                                    It rises to 139% (17 March 2020), from 109%: a larger α reacts more to each day’s shock. With the multiplier 0.25 the peak falls to 64% and moves to 25 March 2020. These are extra runs of the filter, not estimates.

                                    Step 2: the estimated DCC

                                    Slide 33: Step 2: the estimated DCC
                                    Slide 33
                                      Question for the room ▶ holds b at 0.98 and then at 0.99. With b = 0.99, is constant correlation still rejected?
                                      Answer

                                      Yes: the best a on the grid, 0.0074, gives LR = 121.0, far above 5.99. With b = 0.90 the best a is 0.0375 and LR = 102.1: the likelihood has a ridge along which a and b partly replace each other; the maximum, 131.8, is at the estimate (0.0152, 0.9766).

                                      DCC correlation of the S&P 500 and the DAX

                                      Slide 34: DCC correlation of the S&P 500 and the DAX
                                      Slide 34
                                        Question for the room ▶ raises a up to 0.022 (b fixed). What happens to the standard deviation of the DCC correlation (0.083 at the estimate)?
                                        Answer

                                        It rises to 0.120, close to the 250-day rolling correlation (0.122), and the correlation ranges from 0.19 to 0.82. The LR falls to 100.1: the extra variation is noise that the likelihood penalises. With a = 0 the correlation is constant, 0.575, and LR = 0.

                                        Correlations in crises

                                        Slide 36: Correlations in crises
                                        Slide 36
                                          Question for the room ▶ raises a up to 0.022. What happens to the gap between the mean DCC correlation of 2020 and that of the calm period (0.70 − 0.56 = 0.14)?
                                          Answer

                                          It widens to 0.18 (0.73 against 0.55); with a = 0 all three means are 0.575. The sample correlation of the returns (choose it in the box) gives 0.74 and 0.52: it rises mechanically with the volatility (Forbes and Rigobon), while DCC works with the standardised residuals.

                                          DCC correlation in the crises of 2008 and 2020

                                          Slide 37: DCC correlation in the crises of 2008 and 2020
                                          Slide 37
                                            Question for the room ▶ raises the multiplier of α up to 2. Does the 2020 correlation still peak before the volatility?
                                            Answer

                                            No: with α doubled the correlation peak, 0.71, is on 12 June 2020, after the volatility peak (139% on 17 March 2020). The larger volatilities of March divide the shocks of those days, so the standardised residuals that drive the DCC recursion are smaller. With the multiplier 0.25 the 2008 volatility peaks only on 2 December 2008 (60%).

                                            Five markets: S&P 500, DAX, BET, EUR/RON, Bitcoin

                                            A five-asset DCC

                                            Slide 40: A five-asset DCC
                                            Slide 40
                                              Question for the room ▶ shows each asset in turn. Which one has the highest volatility peak, and when?
                                              Answer

                                              Bitcoin: 281% on 13 March 2020. The S&P 500 reaches 121% on 17 March 2020, the DAX 84% on 13 March 2020, the BET 98% on 20 December 2018 (the day on which the DCC hedge ratio reaches 1.00), EUR/RON 13% on 21 May 2025.

                                              Dynamic correlations of four pairs

                                              Slide 41: Dynamic correlations of four pairs
                                              Slide 41
                                                Question for the room ▶ raises a up to 0.02. What happens to the range of the S&P 500 – Bitcoin correlation (−0.05 … 0.42)?
                                                Answer

                                                It widens: from −0.33 to 0.62, with the mean still 0.21. With a = 0 the four correlations become constant, equal to Q̄: 0.55, 0.32, 0.21 and −0.07; this is the CCC model, rejected by LR = 88.5.

                                                Average correlations: calm against crisis

                                                Slide 43: Average correlations: calm against crisis
                                                Slide 43
                                                  Question for the room ▶ raises a up to 0.02. What happens to the average correlation in the 2020 crash (0.19)?
                                                  Answer

                                                  It rises to 0.23, while the calm-period average falls to 0.10. With a = 0 the two matrices are identical (average 0.135): with constant correlations no rise in the crisis can be seen.

                                                  Portfolio VaR 1% with DCC

                                                  Worked example: VaR 1% of two assets

                                                  Slide 47: Worked example: VaR 1% of two assets
                                                  Slide 47

                                                  Worked example

                                                  \[\mathbf{H}_t=\mathbf{D}_t\mathbf{R}_t\mathbf{D}_t,\quad \sigma_{p,t}=\sqrt{\mathbf{w}^\top\mathbf{H}_t\mathbf{w}},\quad \mathrm{VaR}_{0.01,t}=-(\mu_p+z_{0.01}\,\sigma_{p,t}),\ \ z_{0.01}=-2.326\]
                                                      Question for the room ▶ raises ρt up to 1. What is the VaR 1% for ρt = 1?
                                                      Answer

                                                      3.14%: σp = 0.5 · 1.5 + 0.5 · 1.2 = 1.35%, the largest possible value with these volatilities. With ρt = −0.5 the VaR 1% is 1.60%, about 16.0 thousand lei for 1 million lei.

                                                      VaR 1% of an S&P 500 and DAX portfolio, 2015–2026

                                                      Slide 50: VaR 1% of an S&P 500 and DAX portfolio, 2015–2026
                                                      Slide 50
                                                        Question for the room ▶ moves to the levels 2.5% and 5%. At 5%, what is the violation rate of the static VaR?
                                                        Answer

                                                        2.83% (82 violations against 145 expected): too few, LRuc = 33.6, p < 0.001. At 1% the static VaR passed the test (0.90%, p = 0.577): it is too high in calm years, which at 1% offsets the violations of the crises and at 5% does not. DCC with FHS has a rate of 4.60% at 5% (p = 0.314).

                                                        Interpreting the backtest

                                                        Slide 51: Interpreting the backtest
                                                        Slide 51
                                                          Question for the room ▶ moves to the levels 2.5% and 5%. At 5%, does any model pass the Christoffersen independence test?
                                                          Answer

                                                          No: all four have p ≤ 0.0004; the violations come in clusters on the turbulent days. At 2.5% only DCC with FHS passes the Kupiec test (79 violations, a rate of 2.73%, p = 0.433).

                                                          Dynamic hedge ratios

                                                          Worked example: a hedge ratio

                                                          Slide 54: Worked example: a hedge ratio
                                                          Slide 54

                                                          Worked example

                                                          \[h^*=\frac{\sigma_{sf}}{\sigma_f^2}=\rho\,\frac{\sigma_s}{\sigma_f},\qquad HE=1-\frac{\mathrm{Var}(r_s-h^*r_f)}{\mathrm{Var}(r_s)}=\rho^2\]
                                                              Question for the room Set ρ = −0.8. What are h* and HE?
                                                              Answer

                                                              h* = −0.96: buy 0.96 units of f per unit of s; HE = ρ2 = 0.64, as for ρ = 0.8. With ρ = 1 the volatility of the hedged position is 0 (h* = 1.2).

                                                              Hedging the BET with the DAX, 2015–2026

                                                              Slide 55: Hedging the BET with the DAX, 2015–2026
                                                              Slide 55
                                                                Question for the room ▶ lengthens the OLS window up to 500 days. Does rolling OLS then remove more risk than DCC (19.1%)?
                                                                Answer

                                                                No: between 17.0% (300 days) and 18.0% (500 days). With a = 0 in the DCC the effectiveness falls to 15.5%, still above the static ratio (13.6%): the correlation is then constant, but the ratio q̄ σBET,t/σDAX,t still follows the GARCH volatilities.

                                                                Interpreting the hedge ratios

                                                                Slide 56: Interpreting the hedge ratios
                                                                Slide 56
                                                                  Question for the room Is there a window (60–500 days) for which rolling OLS removes more risk than DCC?
                                                                  Answer

                                                                  No: the best result is 18.6%, with 80 days, below 19.1% for DCC; 300 days give only 17.0%. The choice of the window moves the result by more than a percentage point, and DCC needs no such choice.

                                                                  The daily log returns (in %) of the chapter’s samples, on the common trading days (S&P 500, DAX, BET, EUR/RON, Bitcoin; data/market, EODHD), are not revised and reproduce the numbers of the lecture exactly. The estimates come from the chapter’s code: the GARCH(1,1) models of step 1 (arch package) and the parameters (a, b) of step 2 with their standard errors, for the S&P 500 and the DAX (2000–2026), for the five-asset panel (since 2015), for the 2000–2014 estimation sample of the VaR and for the 2005–2014 sample of the hedge. The browser runs the recursions again: the GARCH variance filter with the given parameters, the DCC recursion, the rolling correlations and slopes, the correlation log-likelihood, the VaR and the Kupiec and Christoffersen tests. Variants that do not appear in the lecture (other windows, other values of a and b, another α of step 1 with the same persistence, other VaR levels, k-day returns, the forecasts without new shocks, the quarterly means) are extra runs of the chapter’s code on the same data; the charts of the “Worked example” boxes, “Asynchronous trading and the bias of daily correlations”, “Two conditions on Hₜ”, “The curse of dimensionality”, “Reading a and b”, “Step 1: two univariate GARCH models”, “Step 2: the estimated DCC”, “Correlations in crises”, “A five-asset DCC”, “Interpreting the backtest” and “Interpreting the hedge ratios” are extra charts for slides that give only numbers.